Grimell Jan
Department of Sociology, Faculty of Social Sciences, Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden.
Front Sociol. 2024 Sep 17;9:1406710. doi: 10.3389/fsoc.2024.1406710. eCollection 2024.
This article takes its starting point in a longitudinal interview study that began in 2013 with the aim of investigating identity reconstruction during the transition from military to civilian life. Annual follow-up interviews were conducted for 3 years, after which there was a break for 7 years until 2023 when a new interview cycle was conducted. The article presents the findings from this interview round. The purpose of the study was to describe the ways in which military identity had impacted the selves and lives of the participants. An inductive approach was employed in the analysis and an abductive approach used in the interpretative phase. The results showed, among other things, that a military identity, containing a particularly strong work ethic, had grown salient over the years. This military identity salience amplified the perception of a contrasting civilian work ethic, which generated moral frustration and even conflict. It was seen as imperative to maintain consistency between a military work ethic and the identity standard as a civilian employee rather than to modify the behavior to another standard, i.e., a civilian standard. These results were counterintuitive given the earlier interview cycles. A military work ethic was generally a powerful asset but could have negative health outcomes, manifesting as burnout. The results reflect the challenges in operating multiple identities tailored to contrasting moral regimes. Future longitudinal qualitative and quantitative research approaches to self-identity work among former service members are warranted.
本文始于一项始于2013年的纵向访谈研究,旨在调查从军队生活过渡到平民生活期间的身份重建。连续三年进行年度随访访谈,之后中断7年,直到2023年开始新的访谈周期。本文呈现了本轮访谈的结果。该研究的目的是描述军事身份对参与者的自我和生活产生影响的方式。分析采用归纳法,解释阶段采用溯因法。结果显示,除其他外,多年来,包含特别强烈职业道德的军事身份变得突出。这种军事身份的显著性放大了对平民职业道德差异的认知,从而产生道德挫折甚至冲突。人们认为,保持军事职业道德与文职员工身份标准之间的一致性至关重要,而不是将行为改变为另一种标准,即平民标准。鉴于早期的访谈周期,这些结果是违反直觉的。军事职业道德通常是一项强大的资产,但可能产生负面健康后果,表现为倦怠。这些结果反映了在操作为不同道德体系量身定制的多重身份时所面临的挑战。未来有必要对退役军人的自我身份工作进行纵向定性和定量研究。