Berke Danielle S, Hotchkiss Maiya, Smith Ash M, Gilbert Craig
Department of Psychology, Hunter College of the City University of New York, New York, NY, USA.
The Graduate Center, City University of New York, New York, NY, USA.
J Child Sex Abus. 2024 Oct 14:1-21. doi: 10.1080/10538712.2024.2414996.
We aimed to characterize and conceptually organize multilevel factors associated with the sexual victimization experiences of trans women and trans feminine people to advance violence prevention interventions for health-equity. Between October 2020 and July 2021, we conducted in-depth interviews with 17 expert informants in New York City, which we transcribed, coded, and analyzed. Qualitative insights were derived through an intensive, team-based iterative coding strategy resulting in the development of an exhaustive set of consensus codes which were organized and interpreted in a multi-level structure. Findings revealed a complex constellation of intersecting macro- and micro-structural mechanisms reinforcing sexual violence. Unique characteristics of this violence were characterized hierarchically in terms of: 1) violence forms (e.g. murder, fetishization), 2) perpetrators (e. g. safety-staff; group assault), 3) contexts (e.g. public accommodations), 4) functions (e.g. gender policing), 5) ideological reinforcers (e.g. transphobia, racism), and 6) structural reinforcers (e.g. legislation; linking access to material means of survival to poverty/illness). Results indicate that acute incidents of sexual victimization are "the tip of the iceberg" of the violence impacting trans communities. The community experts we interviewed (e.g. trans women, violence prevention practitioners, social workers) understand chronic functional, ideological, and structural oppression as inextricable from sexual violence. Multi-level determinants of violence therefore constitute essential targets of sexual violence prevention intervention for this population.
我们旨在描述和从概念上梳理与跨性别女性及跨性别女性气质者性侵害经历相关的多层次因素,以推进促进健康公平的暴力预防干预措施。2020年10月至2021年7月期间,我们对纽约市的17名专家 informant 进行了深入访谈,并对访谈内容进行了转录、编码和分析。通过基于团队的密集迭代编码策略得出定性见解,从而形成了一套详尽的共识编码,并按照多层次结构进行组织和解读。研究结果揭示了强化性暴力的宏观和微观结构机制相互交织的复杂格局。这种暴力的独特特征从以下几个方面进行了分层描述:1)暴力形式(如谋杀、 fetishization),2)施暴者(如安全人员;群体攻击),3)背景(如公共住宿场所),4)作用(如性别监管),5)意识形态强化因素(如恐跨症、种族主义),6)结构强化因素(如立法;将获得物质生存手段与贫困/疾病联系起来)。结果表明,性侵害的急性事件只是影响跨性别群体暴力的“冰山一角”。我们采访的社区专家(如跨性别女性、暴力预防从业者、社会工作者)认为,长期的功能性、意识形态性和结构性压迫与性暴力密不可分。因此,暴力的多层次决定因素构成了针对这一人群的性暴力预防干预的重要目标。