Enke Benjamin
Department of Economics, Harvard University, 1805 Cambridge St, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA.
National Bureau of Economic Research, 1050 Massachusetts Ave, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA.
PNAS Nexus. 2024 Oct 15;3(10):pgae309. doi: 10.1093/pnasnexus/pgae309. eCollection 2024 Oct.
Political disagreement is increasingly moral, rather than economic, in nature, raising the question how the fields of political economy and moral psychology relate to each other. While these disciplines were initially deeply intertwined, cross-disciplinary exchange became rare throughout the 20th century. More recently, the tide has shifted again-social scientists of different backgrounds recognized that morality and politico-economic outcomes influence each other in rich bidirectional ways. Because psychologists and economists possess distinct and complementary skill sets, part of this movement consists of productive "economic imperialism"-economists leveraging their empirical toolkit to test and substantiate theories from moral psychology at scale or in the wild. To illustrate this, I present two case studies of recent economics research on prominent ideas in moral psychology. First is the theory that morality is ultimately functional-that it evolved as a form of "psychological and biological police" to enforce cooperation, such as in economic production and exchange. Second is that the structure of morality shapes political views and polarization, including on economic issues such as taxation and redistribution. I conclude from these case studies that economists have much to gain from integrating more ideas from moral psychology, and that moral psychologists will be able to make an even more compelling case if they engage with research in economics.
政治分歧在本质上越来越多地是道德层面的,而非经济层面的,这就引发了一个问题:政治经济学和道德心理学领域彼此之间是如何关联的。虽然这些学科最初紧密交织,但在整个20世纪,跨学科交流变得很少见。最近,潮流再次转变——不同背景的社会科学家认识到,道德与政治经济结果以丰富的双向方式相互影响。由于心理学家和经济学家拥有独特且互补的技能组合,这一趋势的一部分包括富有成效的“经济帝国主义”——经济学家利用他们的实证工具大规模地或在实际场景中检验和证实来自道德心理学的理论。为了说明这一点,我展示了两个近期经济学研究的案例,这些研究围绕道德心理学中的重要观点展开。第一个是道德最终具有功能性的理论——它作为一种“心理和生物警察”的形式演化而来,以促进合作,比如在经济生产和交换中。第二个是道德结构塑造政治观点和两极分化,包括在税收和再分配等经济问题上。从这些案例研究中我得出结论,经济学家若能整合更多来自道德心理学的观点将大有裨益,而道德心理学家若参与经济学研究,将能够提出更有说服力的观点。