Department of Hematology & Oncology, Shanghai Children's Medical Center, Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine, National Children's Medical Center (Shanghai), Shanghai, China.
Washington University School of Medicine, Department of Surgery, St Louis, Missouri.
JAMA Netw Open. 2024 Oct 1;7(10):e2440258. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.40258.
Childhood cancer survivorship programs and long-term follow-up (LTFU) practices are inadequate in most regions of China.
To understand the clinician and caregiver perceptions of LTFU care and to identify barriers to adherence to LTFU care in mainland China.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This survey study had a 2-phase sequential mixed-methods approach, consisting of a cross-sectional survey followed by semistructured interviews. Participants included oncology clinicians recruited through an educational seminar on LTFU and caregivers recruited through convenience sampling. Data were collected from November 2022 to September 2023.
The clinician survey and interview focused on the standards and resources for LTFU care at their practicing institution and barriers to the coordination of LTFU care. For caregivers, the survey and interview focused on their awareness of and participation in LTFU care and their opinions on future LTFU care visits.
A total of 101 clinicians (28 [27.7%] male; 73 [72.3%] female; 46 [45.6%] aged >40 to 50 years) completed the survey (response rate: 90.2%) representing 32 institutions from 22 provinces. As for the caregivers' survey, 164 eligible participants (36 [22.0%] male; 128 [78.0%] female) were recruited (response rate: 20.2%). The majority of the caregivers had received a high school or greater education (96 [56.7%]) and were parents of CCSs diagnosed with leukemia (67 [40.9%]), lymphoma or solid tumors (47 [28.7%]), or conditions requiring hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (50 [30.5%]). Most clinicians (74 [73.3%]) reported providing late effects care, yet only 10 (13.5%) had a dedicated follow-up clinic for CCSs. Two-thirds (64 [63.4%]) reported that the LTFU plan for each survivor is solely determined by their clinical judgment. In structured interviews, all doctors admitted to deviating from published guidelines due to challenges in implementing screening recommendations in their settings. Barriers to providing LTFU services included patient-related factors (76 [75.2%]), survivor knowledge deficits (61 [60.4%]), and the absence of dedicated LTFU clinics (61 [60.4%]). Among caregivers responding to the survey, 60 (36.6%) had never heard of late effects. Overall, 22 of 26 caregivers (84.6%) who participated in the interviews were not aware of potential late effects, although 17 (68.0%) could articulate existing conditions and symptoms that their children were experiencing.
In this mixed-methods study involving clinicians and caregivers, substantial disparities in the uniformity and accessibility of LTFU in China were observed, suggesting the imperative need for a standardized approach to LTFU care for survivors. This includes advocating for establishment of dedicated clinics, alongside an emphasis on enhanced education and training for both clinicians and caregivers.
在中国大多数地区,儿童癌症生存者计划和长期随访(LTFU)实践不足。
了解临床医生和护理人员对 LTFU 护理的看法,并确定遵守中国大陆 LTFU 护理的障碍。
设计、设置和参与者:这项调查研究采用了两阶段顺序混合方法,包括横断面调查和半结构式访谈。参与者包括通过 LTFU 教育研讨会招募的肿瘤学临床医生和通过方便抽样招募的护理人员。数据收集于 2022 年 11 月至 2023 年 9 月。
临床医生的调查和访谈侧重于他们所在机构 LTFU 护理的标准和资源,以及协调 LTFU 护理的障碍。对于护理人员,调查和访谈侧重于他们对 LTFU 护理的认识和参与,以及他们对未来 LTFU 护理就诊的看法。
共有 101 名临床医生(28 名[27.7%]男性;73 名[72.3%]女性;46 名[45.6%]年龄在 40 至 50 岁之间)完成了调查(回应率:90.2%),代表来自 22 个省的 32 个机构。至于护理人员的调查,有 164 名合格参与者(36 名[22.0%]男性;128 名[78.0%]女性)被招募(回应率:20.2%)。大多数护理人员接受过高中或以上教育(96 名[56.7%]),是 CCSs 的父母,诊断为白血病(67 名[40.9%])、淋巴瘤或实体瘤(47 名[28.7%]),或需要造血干细胞移植的疾病(50 名[30.5%])。大多数临床医生(74 名[73.3%])报告提供晚期效应护理,但只有 10 名(13.5%)有专门的 CCS 随访诊所。三分之二(64 名[63.4%])的临床医生报告说,每个幸存者的 LTFU 计划完全取决于他们的临床判断。在结构式访谈中,所有医生都承认由于在其环境中实施筛查建议的挑战,他们偏离了已发表的指南。提供 LTFU 服务的障碍包括患者相关因素(76 名[75.2%])、幸存者知识缺陷(61 名[60.4%])和缺乏专门的 LTFU 诊所(61 名[60.4%])。在参与调查的护理人员中,60 名(36.6%)从未听说过晚期效应。总的来说,26 名参加访谈的护理人员中有 22 名(84.6%)不知道潜在的晚期效应,尽管 17 名(68.0%)可以说出他们的孩子正在经历的现有状况和症状。
在这项涉及临床医生和护理人员的混合方法研究中,中国 LTFU 的统一性和可及性存在显著差异,这表明需要为幸存者制定标准化的 LTFU 护理方法。这包括提倡建立专门的诊所,并强调加强临床医生和护理人员的教育和培训。