Department of Medical Statistics, School of Public Health, Sun Yat-Sen University, Guangzhou, China.
School of Government, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, China.
J Med Internet Res. 2024 Oct 21;26:e54902. doi: 10.2196/54902.
Telemedicine provides remote health care services to overcome constraints of time and space in accessing medical care. Similarly, internet hospitals in China support and provide remote health care services. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, there has been a proliferation of internet hospitals. Many new services, including online consultations and regular online follow-up visit services, can now be accessed via internet hospitals in China. However, the accessibility, cost, and quality advantages of regular online follow-up visit services remain unclear.
This study aimed to evaluate the accessibility, costs, and quality of an online regular follow-up visit service provided by an internet hospital in China. By analyzing the accessibility, costs, and quality of this service from the supply and demand sides, we can summarize the practical and theoretical experiences.
A mixed methods study was conducted using clinical records from 18,473 patients receiving 39,239 online regular follow-up visit services at an internet hospital in 2021, as well as interviews with 7 physicians, 2 head nurses, and 3 administrative staff members. The quantitative analysis examined patient demographics, diagnoses, prescriptions, geographic distribution, physician characteristics, accessibility (travel time and costs), and service hours. The qualitative analysis elucidated physician perspectives on ensuring the quality of online health care.
Patients were predominantly middle-aged men with chronic diseases like viral hepatitis who were located near the hospital. The vast majority were from Guangdong province where the hospital is based, especially concentrated in Guangzhou city. The online regular follow-up visit service reduced travel time by 1 hour to 9 hours and costs by ¥6 to ¥991 (US $0.86-$141.32) depending on proximity, with greater savings for patients farther from the hospital. Consultation times were roughly equivalent between online and in-person visits. Physicians provided most online services during lunch breaks (12 PM to 2 PM) or after work hours (7 PM to 11 PM), indicating increased workload. The top departments providing online regular follow-up visit services were Infectious Diseases, Rheumatology, and Dermatology. The most commonly prescribed medications aligned with the prevalent chronic diagnoses. To ensure quality, physicians conducted initial in-person consultations to fully evaluate patients before allowing online regular follow-up visits, during which they communicated with patients to assess conditions and determine if in-person care was warranted. They also periodically reminded patients to come in person for more comprehensive evaluations. However, they acknowledged online visits cannot fully replace face-to-face care.
Telemedicine services such as online regular follow-up visit services provided by internet hospitals must strictly adhere to fundamental medical principles of diagnosis, prescription, and treatment. For patients with chronic diseases, online regular follow-up visit services improve accessibility and reduce cost but cannot fully replace in-person evaluations. Physicians leverage various strategies to ensure the quality of online care.
远程医疗提供远程医疗服务,以克服在获得医疗服务方面的时间和空间限制。同样,中国的互联网医院也支持并提供远程医疗服务。由于 COVID-19 大流行,互联网医院的数量迅速增加。现在,中国的互联网医院可以提供许多新的服务,包括在线咨询和定期在线随访服务。然而,定期在线随访服务的可及性、成本和质量优势仍不清楚。
本研究旨在评估中国互联网医院提供的在线定期随访服务的可及性、成本和质量。通过从供需双方分析该服务的可及性、成本和质量,我们可以总结实践和理论经验。
采用混合方法研究,对 2021 年在一家互联网医院接受 39239 次在线定期随访服务的 18473 例患者的临床记录以及对 7 名医生、2 名护士长和 3 名行政人员的访谈进行了分析。定量分析检查了患者的人口统计学特征、诊断、处方、地理分布、医生特征、可及性(旅行时间和费用)和服务时间。定性分析阐明了医生对确保在线医疗质量的看法。
患者主要是患有病毒性肝炎等慢性病的中年男性,他们位于医院附近。绝大多数来自互联网医院所在的广东省,尤其是广州市。在线定期随访服务减少了 1 小时至 9 小时的旅行时间和 6 元至 991 元(0.86 美元至 141.32 美元)的费用,具体取决于距离,对于远离医院的患者,节省的费用更多。在线咨询时间与面对面咨询时间大致相同。医生主要在午餐时间(12 点至 2 点)或下班后(7 点至 11 点)提供在线服务,这表明工作量增加了。提供在线定期随访服务的主要科室是传染病科、风湿科和皮肤科。最常开的药物与常见的慢性疾病相符。为了确保质量,医生在允许在线定期随访之前,会进行初步的面对面咨询,以充分评估患者的情况,在此期间,他们与患者沟通,评估病情,并确定是否需要亲自就诊。他们还定期提醒患者亲自来进行更全面的评估。然而,他们承认在线就诊不能完全替代面对面就诊。
互联网医院提供的远程医疗服务,如在线定期随访服务,必须严格遵守诊断、处方和治疗的基本医疗原则。对于慢性病患者,在线定期随访服务提高了可及性并降低了成本,但不能完全替代面对面评估。医生利用各种策略来确保在线护理的质量。