Nguyen Tan T, Bezdek Matthew A, Gershman Samuel J, Bobick Aaron F, Braver Todd S, Zacks Jeffrey M
Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, Washington University in St. Louis, St. Louis, MO 63130, USA.
Department of Psychology and Center for Brain Science, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA.
PNAS Nexus. 2024 Oct 11;3(10):pgae459. doi: 10.1093/pnasnexus/pgae459. eCollection 2024 Oct.
Humans form sequences of -representations of the current situation-to predict how activity will unfold. Multiple mechanisms have been proposed for how the cognitive system determines when to segment the stream of behavior and switch from one active event model to another. Here, we constructed a computational model that learns knowledge about event classes (event schemas), by combining recurrent neural networks for short-term dynamics with Bayesian inference over event classes for event-to-event transitions. This architecture represents event schemas and uses them to construct a series of event models. This architecture was trained on one pass through 18 h of naturalistic human activities. Another 3.5 h of activities were used to test each variant for agreement with human segmentation and categorization. The architecture was able to learn to predict human activity, and it developed segmentation and categorization approaching human-like performance. We then compared two variants of this architecture designed to better emulate human event segmentation: one transitioned when the active event model produced high uncertainty in its prediction and the other transitioned when the active event model produced a large prediction error. The two variants learned to segment and categorize events, and the prediction uncertainty variant provided a somewhat closer match to human segmentation and categorization-despite being given no feedback about segmentation or categorization. These results suggest that event model transitioning based on prediction uncertainty or prediction error can reproduce two important features of human event comprehension.
人类形成当前情境的一系列表征,以预测活动将如何展开。关于认知系统如何确定何时分割行为流并从一个活跃事件模型切换到另一个模型,已经提出了多种机制。在这里,我们构建了一个计算模型,通过将用于短期动态的循环神经网络与对事件类别的贝叶斯推理相结合,来学习关于事件类别的知识(事件图式),用于事件到事件的转换。这种架构表示事件图式,并使用它们来构建一系列事件模型。该架构在对18小时的自然人类活动进行一次遍历的过程中进行训练。另外3.5小时的活动用于测试每个变体与人类分割和分类的一致性。该架构能够学会预测人类活动,并发展出接近人类水平的分割和分类能力。然后,我们比较了该架构的两个变体,旨在更好地模拟人类事件分割:一个在活跃事件模型在其预测中产生高不确定性时进行转换,另一个在活跃事件模型产生大的预测误差时进行转换。这两个变体学会了对事件进行分割和分类,并且预测不确定性变体与人类分割和分类的匹配度更高——尽管没有得到关于分割或分类的反馈。这些结果表明,基于预测不确定性或预测误差的事件模型转换可以重现人类事件理解的两个重要特征。