Aroor Sushanth R, Zevallos Cynthia B, Asif Kaiz S, Singh Nishita, Potter-Vig Jennifer, Rodriguez-Calienes Aaron, Menon Bijoy K, Ganesh Aravind, Saver Jeffrey L, Kamel Hooman, Alexandrov Anne W, Jauch Edward C, Miao Zhongrong, Huo Xiaochuan, Ramakrishnan Pankajavalli, Desai Shashvat M, Limaye Kaustubh, El-Ghanem Mohammad, Toth Gabor, Rao Chetan V, Masoud Hesham E, Wang Qingliang Tony, Herial Nabeel A, Atchaneeyasakul Kunakorn, Szeder Viktor, Amuluru Krishna, Urrutia Victor C, Al-Mufti Fawaz, Yavagal Dileep R, Ortega-Gutierrez Santiago
University of Texas Health Science Center, Houston (S.R.A.).
University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics, Iowa City (C.B.Z., S.O.-G.).
Stroke. 2025 Jan;56(1):158-167. doi: 10.1161/STROKEAHA.124.047805. Epub 2024 Oct 25.
The availability of mechanical thrombectomy (MT) for acute ischemic stroke is limited, and vast disparities exist between countries. We aim to create a MT access score to measure the drivers of access to help quantify and accelerate treatment worldwide.
We used a systematic review complemented by a modified Delphi method. In the first of 3 rounds, 4 independent investigators performed a systematic literature review using key search terms that drive MT access, following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. In the second round, a panel of 6 anonymous international experts selected key attributes needed for scoring. In the final round, a total of 12 attributes were selected on consensus, each given a score on a 0 to 3 scale. An ultimate MT access score (range, 0-36) was proposed as a new tool to use in identifying barriers to MT access and assist in providing an initial framework for public health interventions.
Of 2864 abstracts screened, 121 studies were included in the final systematic review. A total of 34 attributes that potentially drive MT access were initially identified. In the final round, 12 attributes were selected by the expert panel: public awareness, emergency medical services transportation, prehospital large vessel occlusion screening, interhospital transfer policy, emergency department protocols, stroke imaging protocols, emergency department stroke expertise or telestroke availability, interventionalists, MT-capable centers, device availability, and insurance coverage. These attributes were weighted as part of the final score of 0 to 36.
The MT access score represents the first tool to quantify barriers to global MT access. Its implementation stands not just as an academic achievement but as a beacon of hope for improving stroke care and outcomes worldwide, bringing us a step closer to bridging the gap in stroke treatment disparities.
急性缺血性卒中机械取栓术(MT)的可及性有限,且各国之间存在巨大差异。我们旨在创建一个MT可及性评分,以衡量影响可及性的因素,从而在全球范围内帮助量化并加速治疗。
我们采用了系统评价,并辅以改良的德尔菲法。在三轮中的第一轮,4名独立研究人员按照系统评价与Meta分析的首选报告项目指南,使用驱动MT可及性的关键检索词进行系统文献检索。在第二轮,由6名匿名国际专家组成的小组选择评分所需的关键属性。在最后一轮中,经共识共选择了12个属性,每个属性在0至3分的量表上评分。提出了一个最终的MT可及性评分(范围为0至36),作为一种新工具,用于识别MT可及性的障碍,并协助提供公共卫生干预的初始框架。
在筛选的2864篇摘要中,121项研究纳入了最终的系统评价。最初共识别出34个可能驱动MT可及性的属性。在最后一轮中,专家小组选择了12个属性:公众意识、紧急医疗服务运输、院前大血管闭塞筛查、院间转运政策、急诊科协议、卒中成像协议、急诊科卒中专业知识或远程卒中服务可及性、介入医生、具备MT能力的中心、设备可及性和保险覆盖范围。这些属性作为最终0至36分评分的一部分进行加权。
MT可及性评分是量化全球MT可及性障碍的首个工具。其实施不仅是一项学术成就,更是改善全球卒中治疗和预后的希望灯塔,使我们在弥合卒中治疗差异方面又迈进了一步。