Berkowitz R, Schwartz E, Bukstein D, Grunstein M, Chai H
Pediatrics. 1986 Feb;77(2):173-8.
Both metaproterenol sulfate and albuterol are inhaled medications commonly used to prevent exercise-induced bronchospasm. Their efficacy and duration of action in controlling exercise-induced bronchospasm were compared with placebo in 18 asthmatic children (age range: 12 to 17 years) in a single-blind randomized crossover study. Standardized treadmill exercise challenges were repeated every two hours for up to six hours following the initial exercise test. With the initial exercise challenge, both active medications blocked exercise-induced bronchospasm with equal efficacy. On the other hand, when the duration of action of the medications was compared: albuterol blocked exercise-induced bronchospasm longer than metaproterenol sulfate in eight subjects, the reverse was true in only one patient, and the medications blocked for equal duration in nine subjects. Thus, although both active agents were equally efficacious in blocking exercise-induced bronchospasm initially, the duration of action of albuterol was significantly (P less than .05) longer on serial testing than that of metaproterenol sulfate. Both medications were significantly better than placebo in efficacy and duration of action.
硫酸间羟异丙肾上腺素和沙丁胺醇都是常用于预防运动诱发性支气管痉挛的吸入药物。在一项单盲随机交叉研究中,对18名哮喘儿童(年龄范围:12至17岁)进行了研究,比较了它们与安慰剂在控制运动诱发性支气管痉挛方面的疗效和作用持续时间。在初始运动测试后的六个小时内,每两小时重复进行标准化的跑步机运动激发试验。在初始运动激发试验中,两种活性药物在阻断运动诱发性支气管痉挛方面疗效相当。另一方面,当比较药物的作用持续时间时:在8名受试者中,沙丁胺醇阻断运动诱发性支气管痉挛的时间比硫酸间羟异丙肾上腺素长,只有1名患者情况相反,在9名受试者中两种药物阻断的持续时间相同。因此,虽然两种活性药物在最初阻断运动诱发性支气管痉挛方面疗效相当,但在连续测试中,沙丁胺醇的作用持续时间比硫酸间羟异丙肾上腺素显著更长(P小于0.05)。两种药物在疗效和作用持续时间方面均显著优于安慰剂。