Cossu Giulia, Ramsay Daniele S C, Daniel Roy T, El Cadhi Ahmed, Kerherve Luc, Morlaix Edouard, Houidi Sayda A, Millot-Piccoli Clément, Chapon Renan, Le Van Tuan, Cao Catherine, Farah Walid, Lleu Maxime, Baland Olivier, Beaurain Jacques, Petit Jean Michel, Lemogne Brivaël, Messerer Mahmoud, Berhouma Moncef
Department of Neurosurgery, University Hospital of Lausanne and University of Lausanne, 1011 Lausanne, Switzerland.
Department of Neurosurgery, University Hospital of Dijon Bourgogne, 21000 Dijon, France.
Cancers (Basel). 2024 Oct 14;16(20):3479. doi: 10.3390/cancers16203479.
: The recent discovery of BRAF mutation in papillary craniopharyngiomas opened new avenues for targeted therapies to control tumour growth, decreasing the need for invasive treatments and relative complications. The aim of this systematic review was to summarize the recent scientific data dealing with the use of targeted therapies in papillary craniopharyngiomas, as adjuvant and neoadjuvant treatments. : The PRISMA guidelines were followed with searches performed in Scopus, MEDLINE, and Embase, following a dedicated PICO approach. : We included 21 pertinent studies encompassing 53 patients: 26 patients received BRAF inhibitors (BRAFi) as adjuvant treatment, while 25 received them as neoadjuvant treatment. In the adjuvant setting, BRAFi were used to treat recurrent tumours after surgery or adjuvant radiation therapy. The most common regimen combined dabrafenib (BRAFi) with trametinib (MEK1 and 2 inhibitor) in 81% of cases. The mean treatment length was 8.8 months (range 1.6 to 28 months) and 32% were continuing BRAFi. A reduction of tumour volume variable from 24% to 100% was observed at cerebral MRI during treatment and volumetric reduction ≥80% was described in 64% of cases. Once the treatment was stopped, adjuvant treatments were performed to stabilize patients in remission in 11 cases (65%) or when a progression was detected in three cases (12%). In four cases no further therapies were administered (16%). Mean follow-up after the end of targeted therapy was 17.1 months. As neoadjuvant regimen, 36% of patients were treated with dabrafenib and trametinib with a near complete radiological response in all the cases with a mean treatment of 5.7 months. The neoadjuvant use of verumafenib (BRAFi) and cometinib (MEK1 inhibitor) induced a near complete response in 15 patients (94%), with a median volumetric reduction between 85% and 91%. Ten patients did not receive further treatments. Side effects varied among studies. The optimal timing, sequencing, and duration of treatment of these new therapies should be established. Moreover, questions remain about the choice of specific BRAF/MEK inhibitors, the optimal protocol of treatment, and the strategies for managing adverse events. : Treatment is shifting to a wider multidisciplinary management, where a key role is played by targeted therapies, to improve outcomes and quality of life for patients with BRAF-mutated craniopharyngiomas. Future, larger comparative trials will optimize their protocol of use and integration into multimodal strategies of treatment.
最近在乳头状颅咽管瘤中发现BRAF突变,为控制肿瘤生长的靶向治疗开辟了新途径,减少了侵入性治疗及相关并发症的需求。本系统评价的目的是总结近期关于乳头状颅咽管瘤靶向治疗作为辅助和新辅助治疗的科学数据。:按照PRISMA指南,采用专门的PICO方法在Scopus、MEDLINE和Embase中进行检索。:我们纳入了21项相关研究,共53例患者:26例患者接受BRAF抑制剂(BRAFi)作为辅助治疗,25例接受其作为新辅助治疗。在辅助治疗中,BRAFi用于治疗手术后或辅助放疗后的复发性肿瘤。最常见的方案是81%的病例将达拉非尼(BRAFi)与曲美替尼(MEK1和2抑制剂)联合使用。平均治疗时长为8.8个月(范围1.6至28个月),32%的患者仍在继续使用BRAFi。治疗期间脑部MRI显示肿瘤体积缩小幅度从24%至100%不等,64%的病例体积缩小≥80%。治疗停止后,11例患者(65%)接受辅助治疗以维持缓解状态,3例患者(12%)在检测到病情进展时接受辅助治疗。4例患者(16%)未接受进一步治疗。靶向治疗结束后的平均随访时间为17.1个月。作为新辅助治疗方案,36%的患者接受达拉非尼和曲美替尼治疗,所有病例均有近乎完全的放射学反应,平均治疗时间为5.7个月。维罗非尼(BRAFi)和考美替尼(MEK1抑制剂)的新辅助治疗在15例患者(94%)中诱导出近乎完全的反应,体积缩小中位数在85%至91%之间。10例患者未接受进一步治疗。不同研究中的副作用各不相同。应确定这些新疗法的最佳治疗时机顺序和持续时间。此外,关于特定BRAF/MEK抑制剂的选择、最佳治疗方案以及不良事件管理策略等问题仍然存在。:治疗正转向更广泛的多学科管理,其中靶向治疗发挥关键作用,以改善BRAF突变型颅咽管瘤患者的治疗效果和生活质量。未来,更大规模的比较试验将优化其使用方案并将其整合到多模式治疗策略中。