Coburn Katelyn O, Vennum Amber, McGeorge Christi R, Stafford Markham Melinda, Spencer Chelsea M
Department of Child, Youth and Family Studies, University of Nebraska-Lincoln, Lincoln, Nebraska, USA.
Department of Applied Human Sciences, Kansas State University, Manhattan, Kansas, USA.
Int J Transgend Health. 2023 Oct 16;25(4):751-769. doi: 10.1080/26895269.2023.2268052. eCollection 2024.
Nonbinary people experience marginalization through discrimination, rejection, microaggressions, and stigma as a result of not always conforming to societal gender norms embedded in the gender binary. There is limited research about how nonbinary Black, Indigenous, and People of Color (BIPOC) living in the United States navigate societally enforced binary gender norms, which is especially important to understand given how racism and Euro-colonization have enforced the gender binary. Better understanding the internal strategies nonbinary people use to cope, embody affirmation, and regulate emotions in response to marginalizing experiences could increase understanding of how to best prevent and address the health disparities experienced by nonbinary people. Drawing on the practices of interrogating norms central to queer theory with a sensitization to racism and settler colonialism, this study aimed to identify a framework to understand nonbinary peoples' processes of navigating gender norms internally through their lived experiences with an awareness of how context impacts these processes. This qualitative interview study utilized construcitivist grounded theory methodology, guided by queer theory. Twenty-one nonbinary individuals were interviewed over Zoom with 15 being BIPOC. Participants navigated binary gender norms internally by self-defining affirmative nonbinary ways of being, noticing affirmation in a chosen community that allowed them to experience existing authentically outside of binary gender norms, and internally connecting to an embodied, authentic sense of gender within themselves and in community with other nonbinary people. These internal processes were influenced by two contextual factors: societal and cultural expectations of gender; and the contextual impacts of holding multiple marginalized identities. Understanding the contexts of the gender binary, racism, and cissexism that impact nonbinary people on a daily basis is crucial for mental health professionals, researchers, policy makers, and creators of gender inclusive education and support programs to support and affirm nonbinary people.
非二元性别人士由于不总是符合二元性别体系中所嵌入的社会性别规范,而遭受歧视、排斥、微歧视和污名化等边缘化待遇。关于生活在美国的非二元性别的黑人、原住民和有色人种(BIPOC)如何应对社会强制推行的二元性别规范的研究有限,鉴于种族主义和欧洲殖民主义对二元性别体系的强化,了解这一点尤为重要。更好地理解非二元性别人士用来应对、体现自我肯定以及调节情绪以回应边缘化经历的内在策略,有助于增进对如何最好地预防和解决非二元性别人士所经历的健康差距的理解。借鉴酷儿理论中对规范进行审视的实践,并对种族主义和定居者殖民主义保持敏感,本研究旨在确定一个框架,以通过非二元性别人士的生活经历来理解他们在内部应对性别规范的过程,并认识到背景如何影响这些过程。这项定性访谈研究采用了建构主义扎根理论方法,以酷儿理论为指导。通过Zoom对21名非二元性别人士进行了访谈,其中15名是BIPOC。参与者通过自我定义肯定性的非二元存在方式在内部应对二元性别规范,在一个选定的社区中注意到自我肯定,这使他们能够在二元性别规范之外真实地存在,并且在内部与自己以及与其他非二元性别人士的社区中所体现的真实性别感建立联系。这些内部过程受到两个背景因素的影响:社会和文化对性别的期望;以及拥有多种边缘化身份的背景影响。对于心理健康专业人员、研究人员、政策制定者以及性别包容性教育和支持项目的创造者来说,了解每天影响非二元性别人士的二元性别体系、种族主义和顺性别歧视的背景,对于支持和肯定非二元性别人士至关重要。