Anyfantakis Dimitrios, Tsoucalas Gregory, Karelis Andreas, Papazoglou Nikolaos, Spandidos Demetrios A, Krasagakis Konstantinos, Symvoulakis Emmanouil
Primary Health Care Centre of Kissamos, 73134 Chania, Greece.
Department of History of Medicine and Deontology of Medicine, School of Medicine, University of Crete, 71003 Heraklion, Greece.
Exp Ther Med. 2024 Oct 11;28(6):453. doi: 10.3892/etm.2024.12743. eCollection 2024 Dec.
Hematidrosis constitutes a rare imposing phenomenon encountered millennia ago. It involves the plexus of small, mostly superficial arteries, veins and sweat glands of various parts of the human body. Bloody sweat implies skin pathology. It has been connected to psychogenic impairment and lacks a clear etiology. The present study conducted a historical review using the Thesaurus Linguae Graecae, Gallica-BNF and Google Books databases. The year 1900 was the mark for full-text works to be included. A second review of the modern literature, over the last 20 years, was carried out using the PubMed/MedLine database. In both eras, the terms h[a]emat[h]idrosis, diapedesis, sudor sanguineus, plus various others vocables of Hellenic and Latin origin, were used as key words. Cases of persons suffering hematidrosis during stigmata as partly connected to this study were surveyed and discussed separately. References were obtained from the classical Greece, late Hellenic antiquity and Roman era. A number of 70 cases were registered from the Renaissance to 1900, and 44 cases between 2007 and 2022. The later time interval is considered as the selection of references of all time, while the 1870 to 1884 interval followed. Differences in sex were observed (males, 60.6%; and females, 39.4%; vs. males, 25.6%; and females, 74.4%). The scalp, forehead, face, trunk, arms and legs were the most common areas of appearance in both time intervals. The eyes and ears were the most common areas of appearance in the modern era. As regards the limitations of the present review, it should be emphasized that not all historical cases were available for survey. Stigmata were studied independently. Records in etiology hypothesis, pathological description and the manifestation of a cluster of post-triggering effects described were similar over time. The modern way of life, major stressful events, a fear of death, hematological disorders, vessel derangements and deep faith may trigger hematidrosis. This spectacular acute event stimulates alertness in patients, family, caregivers and physicians, and may lead to social isolation and unnecessary diagnostic and/or therapeutic interventions. The present narrative review aimed to connect science with history and religion, promote contemplation among health professionals and highlight a medical peculiarity. An open mind is warranted in order to comprehend phenomena in religion. Education for the family and a knowledge update for health professionals is also necessary.
血汗症是一种罕见且引人注目的现象,数千年前就已被发现。它涉及人体各部位的小血管丛,主要是浅表动脉、静脉和汗腺。血汗意味着皮肤病变。它与心理性损伤有关,病因尚不明确。本研究使用希腊语宝库、法国国家图书馆和谷歌图书数据库进行了历史回顾。1900年是纳入全文著作的时间节点。利用PubMed/MedLine数据库对过去20年的现代文献进行了二次回顾。在这两个时期,“血汗症”“血细胞渗出”“血性汗液”以及其他一些希腊语和拉丁语来源的词汇都被用作关键词。对在圣痕期间患血汗症的病例进行了调查,并将其与本研究部分相关的情况单独进行了讨论。参考文献来自古希腊、希腊化晚期和罗马时代。从文艺复兴到1900年记录了70例病例,2007年至2022年记录了44例病例。后一个时间段被视为有史以来参考文献的选择,其次是1870年至1884年的时间段。观察到性别差异(男性占60.6%,女性占39.4%;与之相比,男性占25.6%,女性占74.4%)。在这两个时间段,头皮、前额、面部、躯干、手臂和腿部都是最常见的出现部位。在现代,眼睛和耳朵是最常见的出现部位。关于本综述的局限性,应该强调的是,并非所有历史病例都可供调查。圣痕是独立研究的。随着时间的推移,病因假设、病理描述以及所描述的一系列触发后效应的表现记录相似。现代生活方式、重大压力事件、对死亡的恐惧、血液系统疾病、血管紊乱和坚定的信仰可能引发血汗症。这一惊人的急性事件会引起患者、家人、护理人员和医生的警觉,并可能导致社会隔离以及不必要的诊断和/或治疗干预。本叙述性综述旨在将科学与历史和宗教联系起来,促进卫生专业人员的思考,并突出一种医学特殊性。为了理解宗教中的现象,需要有开放的思维。对家庭进行教育以及为卫生专业人员更新知识也是必要的。