Hlay Jessica K, Johnson Benjamin N, Hodges-Simeon Carolyn R, Levy Kenneth N
Department of Anthropology, Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
School of Psychology and Counseling, Fairleigh Dickinson University, Teaneck, New Jersey, USA.
J Pers Assess. 2025 May-Jun;107(3):346-360. doi: 10.1080/00223891.2024.2413148. Epub 2024 Oct 31.
In response to Cannon's widely accepted fight-or-flight system, Taylor et al. proposed the tend-and-befriend hypothesis to better capture variance in women's stress response behaviors. The Tend-and-Befriend Questionnaire (TBQ) measures self-reported individual differences in the use of fight, flight, tend, and befriend. Several studies have used this scale to evaluate sex differences in these behaviors, yet it has not yet been rigorously evaluated. Using three samples ( = 1094), we first explore the factor structure of the TBQ to produce and validate a revised measure, the TBQ-Short Form (TBQ-SF). Next, we evaluate the claim that women use tend-and-befriend more than men. Results indicated that the TBQ-SF provided both reliable subscales and largely acceptable model fit, yet the factor structure and validity varied across the three samples. While men do report more fighting than women, men and women report use tending and befriending more than fighting or fleeing. Finally, other variables-namely attachment-capture more variance in TBQ-SF factors than sex. While the TBQ-SF does capture differences in stress reactions (fight, flight, tend/befriend), we suggest that the scale is most reliable in measuring overall stress reactivity. Therefore, future research should aim to construct a better scale specific to tend-and-befriend using alternative methodologies.
针对坎农被广泛接受的“战斗或逃跑”系统,泰勒等人提出了“照料与结盟”假说,以更好地捕捉女性应激反应行为的差异。“照料与结盟”问卷(TBQ)测量了在战斗、逃跑、照料和结盟行为使用方面自我报告的个体差异。几项研究使用该量表评估了这些行为中的性别差异,但尚未对其进行严格评估。我们使用三个样本(N = 1094),首先探索TBQ的因子结构,以编制和验证一个修订后的测量工具,即TBQ简表(TBQ-SF)。接下来,我们评估女性比男性更多地使用照料与结盟这一说法。结果表明,TBQ-SF提供了可靠的分量表,且模型拟合度在很大程度上可以接受,但因子结构和效度在三个样本中有所不同。虽然男性确实比女性报告更多的战斗行为,但男性和女性报告使用照料和结盟行为的频率高于战斗或逃跑行为。最后,其他变量——即依恋——在TBQ-SF因子中比性别捕捉到更多的变异。虽然TBQ-SF确实捕捉到了应激反应(战斗、逃跑、照料/结盟)的差异,但我们认为该量表在测量总体应激反应性方面最可靠。因此,未来的研究应以使用替代方法构建一个更适合照料与结盟的量表为目标。