Geda Wolde Abreham, Anticho Tariku Lambiyo, Ormago Moges Desta
Sidama Regional Public Health Institute, Hawassa, Sidaama, Ethiopia.
University School of Medical Laboratory Science, Hawassa, Ethiopia.
SAGE Open Med. 2024 Sep 20;12:20503121241274716. doi: 10.1177/20503121241274716. eCollection 2024.
We aimed to assess performance parameters in a Hawassa Tuberculosis Culture Laboratory, in the Sidama Regional Public Health Institute.
A cross-sectional survey was conducted between 27 October 2020 and 31 May 2021, on 439 clinical specimens. The specimens were processed using standard procedures, and the final suspension was inoculated into a Microbial Growth Indicator Tube and Lowenstein-Jensen media slant. Ziehl-Neelsen staining and the Bioline test kit were used to identify and confirm Mycobacterium tuberculosis. The data were analyzed using the IBM Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS, version 26).
Out of a total of 439 specimens that were processed, the recovery rates for smear-positive specimens were 61% (25 out of 41) and 58.5% (24 out of 41) for the Mycobacterial Growth Indicator Tube, and the Lowenstein-Jensen methods, respectively. For smear-negative samples, the recovery rates were 4.5% (18 out of 398) for both methods. Only 4 (0.9%) specimens were rejected. The mean turnaround times to detect mycobacteria from smear-positive samples were 14 and 32 days for the Mycobacterial Growth Indicator Tube and Lowenstein-Jensen methods, respectively. The standard deviations were ±6.3 days and ±9.7 days, respectively. For smear-negative samples, the mean turnaround times were 17.7 and 31 days for the Mycobacterial Growth Indicator Tube and Lowenstein-Jensen methods, respectively. The standard deviations were ±9.2 days and ±9.6 days, respectively. The contamination rates for the Mycobacterial Growth Indicator Tube and Lowenstein-Jensen methods were 9.8% (43 out of 439) and 9.6% (42 out of 439), respectively. The detection rate of nontuberculosis mycobacteria was 1.4% (6 out of 439).
It demands attention to improve the low recovery rate among smear-negative cultures and culture contamination rates.
我们旨在评估锡达马地区公共卫生研究所哈瓦萨结核病培养实验室的性能参数。
于2020年10月27日至2021年5月31日对439份临床标本进行了横断面调查。标本采用标准程序处理,最终悬液接种到微生物生长指示管和罗-琴培养基斜面上。采用萋-尼染色和Bioline检测试剂盒鉴定和确认结核分枝杆菌。使用IBM社会科学统计软件包(SPSS,版本26)对数据进行分析。
在总共处理的439份标本中,涂片阳性标本的回收率在微生物生长指示管法和罗-琴法中分别为61%(41份中的25份)和58.5%(41份中的24份)。对于涂片阴性样本,两种方法的回收率均为4.5%(398份中的18份)。仅4份(0.9%)标本被拒收。从涂片阳性样本中检测出分枝杆菌的平均周转时间,微生物生长指示管法和罗-琴法分别为14天和32天。标准差分别为±6.3天和±9.7天。对于涂片阴性样本,微生物生长指示管法和罗-琴法的平均周转时间分别为17.7天和31天。标准差分别为±9.2天和±9.6天。微生物生长指示管法和罗-琴法的污染率分别为9.8%(439份中的43份)和9.6%(439份中的42份)。非结核分枝杆菌的检出率为1.4%(439份中的6份)。
涂片阴性培养物的低回收率和培养污染率需要引起关注以加以改善。