John Denny, Dutta Majumdar Abhirup, Pillai Rakesh N, Khatoon Sajda, Bhattacharya Paramita, Mukherjee Nirmalya, Menon Jaideep C, Pavithran K, Kumar Anand, Jakovljevic Mihajlo
Faculty of Life and Allied Health Sciences, Ramaiah University of Applied Sciences, Bengaluru, India.
Independent Statistician, Kolkata, India.
Int J Technol Assess Health Care. 2024 Nov 4;40(1):e70. doi: 10.1017/S0266462324000345.
The aim of this study is to understand the path for establishing digital health technologies-health technology assessment (DHT-HTA) in India.
A rapid review of HTA and DHT frameworks on PubMed (MEDLINE) and Google Scholar was conducted to identify DHT-HTA guidelines, and HTA processes in India. MS-Excel template was created with key domains for assessing DHT in resource-constrained settings based on studies and reports identified. Responses received from seventeen experts with varying expertise in DHT, HTA, clinical, and research were contacted using an online form. Following the principles of qualitative research rooted on grounded theory approach, themes and domains were derived for a framework which was again circulated through participants. Weightage for each theme was assigned based on the frequency of responses and qualifiers were used to interpret results. Inductively derived themes from these responses were clubbed together to identify macro-level systems requirements, and finally pre-requisites for setting up DHT-HTA framework was synthesized.
HT are commonly perceived by experts (64.7 percent participants) as a technology strictly connected to health information. Real-world data (i.e., electronic health data) are recognized as a relevant tool in support of decision-making for clinical and managerial levels. Experts identified some pre-requisites for the establishment of DHT-HTA in the country in terms of infrastructure, contextual factors, training, finance, data security, and scale-up.
Our research not only identified the pre-requisites for the adoption of a DHT-HTA framework for India, but confirmed the need to address DHT-HTA's acceptability among. Hospitals and health insurance providers.
本研究旨在了解在印度建立数字健康技术-卫生技术评估(DHT-HTA)的路径。
对PubMed(MEDLINE)和谷歌学术上的HTA和DHT框架进行快速回顾,以确定DHT-HTA指南以及印度的HTA流程。根据所确定的研究和报告,创建了MS-Excel模板,其中包含在资源受限环境中评估DHT的关键领域。通过在线表格联系了17位在DHT、HTA、临床和研究方面具有不同专业知识的专家。遵循基于扎根理论方法的定性研究原则,得出了一个框架的主题和领域,并再次分发给参与者。根据回复频率为每个主题分配权重,并使用限定词来解释结果。将这些回复中归纳得出的主题汇总在一起,以确定宏观层面的系统要求,最后综合得出建立DHT-HTA框架的先决条件。
专家们(64.7%的参与者)普遍认为HT是一种与健康信息紧密相关的技术。真实世界数据(即电子健康数据)被认为是支持临床和管理层面决策的相关工具。专家们从基础设施、背景因素、培训、资金、数据安全和扩大规模等方面确定了该国建立DHT-HTA的一些先决条件。
我们的研究不仅确定了印度采用DHT-HTA框架的先决条件,还证实了需要解决DHT-HTA在医院和健康保险提供商中的可接受性问题。