Lager Emil, Sorjonen Kimmo, Melin Marika
Department of Clinical Neuroscience, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
Front Psychol. 2024 Oct 22;15:1402645. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1402645. eCollection 2024.
Gender differences in cognitive and operational abilities have been identified. Yet, their interrelationship remains underexplored. This prevents tailored evidence-based selection, allowing discrimination to persist.
Data from a test battery of operational and cognitive tests was analyzed. In total 2,743 aviation pilot candidates' test scores were analyzed.
Males had a significantly higher score on mental spatial ability, memory retention, abstract problem solving, multitasking ability (MU), and manual spatial ability (MSA); and females on perceptual speed. Correlations between MU and MSA [difference = 0.269 (95% CI: 0.114; 0.405)] and between MSA and perceptual speed [difference = 0.186 (95% CI: 0.027; 0.332)] were significantly stronger among female applicants. A high MSA score was more predictive of a high score on MU, Perceptual speed, and Memory for female compared with male applicants ( < 0.002 for the MSA score × sex interaction effect in all three cases).
Interpretation of test scores in between genders potentially may need to look different for final selection decisions for operational professions, as female test profiles were shown to exhibit greater homogeneity.
认知和操作能力方面的性别差异已得到确认。然而,它们之间的相互关系仍未得到充分探索。这阻碍了基于证据的个性化选拔,使得歧视现象持续存在。
对一系列操作和认知测试的数据进行了分析。总共分析了2743名航空飞行员候选人的测试成绩。
男性在心理空间能力、记忆保持、抽象问题解决、多任务处理能力(MU)和手动空间能力(MSA)方面得分显著更高;而女性在知觉速度方面得分更高。在女性申请者中,MU与MSA之间的相关性[差异=0.269(95%CI:0.114;0.405)]以及MSA与知觉速度之间的相关性[差异=0.186(95%CI:0.027;0.332)]显著更强。与男性申请者相比,高MSA得分对女性在MU、知觉速度和记忆方面的高分更具预测性(在所有三种情况下,MSA得分×性别交互效应的P<0.002)。
对于操作性职业的最终选拔决策,不同性别之间测试成绩的解读可能需要有所不同,因为女性的测试概况显示出更大的同质性。