Routh Jennifer, Paramasivam Sharmini Julita, Cockcroft Peter, Nadarajah Vishna Devi, Jeevaratnam Kamalan
School of Veterinary Medicine, University of Surrey, Guildford, Surrey, GU2 7AL, UK.
Newcastle University Medicine Malaysia, Iskandar Puteri, Johor, Malaysia.
J Vet Med Educ. 2024 Sep 26:e20240041. doi: 10.3138/jvme-2024-0041.
Veterinary students, academics, and clinical supervisors are likely to have different perspectives on what it takes to be prepared for workplace clinical training (WCT). Differing expectations could confuse students if they receive conflicting messages about the skills and attributes to which they should aspire. Furthermore, they may struggle to engage with the affordances that workplaces provide for learning if unprepared. Using a survey, we ranked 91 preparedness characteristics and seven preparedness themes for WCT for importance, according to clinical supervisors, academics, and final-year veterinary students before and after undergoing WCT in a UK veterinary school employing a distributive model of WCT. Statistical analyses were used to determine 1) rank alignment and 2) significant differences in characteristic and theme rank among groups. The correlation among characteristic rankings was strongest between students and clinical supervisors, and weakest between clinical supervisors and academics. Honesty, integrity and dependability was the most important characteristic for students and clinical supervisors, whereas students' awareness that perfection is not expected was the most important characteristic for academics. The "knowledge" theme was ranked as significantly more important for academics compared to students pre-WCT. Therefore, differences in the expectations of students starting WCT have been demonstrated in this study. As the educational setting transitions from "classroom to clinic", academics and students must adapt their notions of preparedness to align with conceptions of learning and teaching in the workplace, while supervisors should be mindful of students' pre-existing expectations. Continuous communication and expectation alignment are necessary for a cohesive curriculum strategy.
兽医专业学生、学者和临床督导员对于为职场临床培训(WCT)做好准备所需的条件可能有不同的看法。如果学生收到关于他们应该追求的技能和特质的相互矛盾的信息,不同的期望可能会让他们感到困惑。此外,如果没有做好准备,他们可能难以利用工作场所提供的学习机会。通过一项调查,我们根据一所采用分布式WCT模式的英国兽医学校的临床督导员、学者以及接受WCT前后的兽医专业最后一年学生,对WCT的91个准备特征和七个准备主题的重要性进行了排名。使用统计分析来确定1)排名一致性,以及2)各群体在特征和主题排名上的显著差异。学生和临床督导员之间的特征排名相关性最强,而临床督导员和学者之间的相关性最弱。诚实、正直和可靠性是学生和临床督导员最重要的特征,而学生意识到不期望完美是学者最重要的特征。与WCT前的学生相比,“知识”主题对学者的重要性被评为显著更高。因此,本研究证明了开始WCT的学生在期望上存在差异。随着教育环境从“课堂到临床”的转变,学者和学生必须调整他们的准备观念,使其与职场学习和教学的概念相一致,而督导员应该注意学生原有的期望。持续的沟通和期望一致对于连贯的课程策略是必要的。