Nielsen V M, Højslet P E, Karlsmose M
J Laryngol Otol. 1986 Feb;100(2):187-90. doi: 10.1017/s0022215100098959.
The purpose of this investigation was to evaluate the extent to which voice quality recovers and is retained in the long term, and the incidence of recurrence of Reinke's oedema, in patients treated by stripping of the vocal cords. Of 120 patients treated consecutively over an eight-year period, 111 comprised the follow-up investigation group. Only 19 per cent had a normal voice. The remaining 81 per cent had voice problems, and of these, 68 per cent displayed obvious hoarseness, with recurrence of Reinke's oedema in 58 per cent. It is concluded that the long term curative effect of this traditional treatment is over-estimated, and that the elimination of various etiological factors, particularly habitual tobacco smoking and voice abuse, is of prime importance.
本研究的目的是评估声带剥脱术治疗的患者声音质量恢复及长期保持的程度,以及声带水肿复发的发生率。在八年期间连续治疗的120例患者中,111例纳入随访调查组。只有19%的患者声音正常。其余81%的患者存在声音问题,其中68%表现为明显嘶哑,58%有声带水肿复发。结论是,这种传统治疗的长期疗效被高估了,消除各种病因,尤其是习惯性吸烟和用声不当,至关重要。