Sheehan Theodore A, Winter-Potter Eliza, Dorste Anna, Meisel Christian, Loddenkemper Tobias
Division of Epilepsy and Clinical Neurophysiology, Department of Neurology, Boston Children's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
Rocky Vista University College of Osteopathic Medicine, Parker, CO, USA.
Epilepsy Curr. 2024 May 16;25(1):9-16. doi: 10.1177/15357597241253426. eCollection 2025 Jan-Feb.
Seizure detection is vital for managing epilepsy as seizures can lead to injury and even death, in addition to impacting quality of life. Prompt detection of seizures and intervention can help prevent injury and improve outcomes for individuals with epilepsy. Wearable sensors show promising results for automated detection of certain seizures, but they have limitations such as patient tolerance, impracticality for newborns, and the need for recharging. Non-contact video and audio-based technologies have become available, but a comprehensive literature review on these methods is lacking. This scoping literature review provides an overview of video and audio-based seizure detection, highlighting their potential benefits and challenges. It encompasses a thorough search and evaluation of relevant articles, summarizing methods and performances of these systems. The primary aim of this review is to examine and analyze existing research to identify patterns and gaps and establish a foundation for future advancements. We screened 7 databases using a set of standardized search criteria to minimize any potential missed articles. Four thousand four hundred eighty-seven deduplicated abstracts were screened and narrowed down to 34 studies that varied in design, algorithm methods, types of seizures detected, and performance metrics. Seizure detection sensitivity ranged from 100% to 0%, with optical flow analysis showing the highest sensitivity. The specificity of all included articles ranged from 97.7% to 60%. While limited studies reported accuracy, the highest reported was 100% using Radon Transform based technique on Dual Tree Complex Wavelet coefficients. Video and audio-based tools offer novel, noncontact approaches for detecting and monitoring seizures. Available studies are limited in sample sizes, dataset diversity, and standardized evaluation protocols, impacting the generalizability of results. Future research focusing on larger-scale investigations with diverse datasets, standardized evaluation protocols, and consistent reporting metrics is needed.
癫痫发作检测对于癫痫管理至关重要,因为癫痫发作除了会影响生活质量外,还可能导致受伤甚至死亡。及时检测癫痫发作并进行干预有助于预防癫痫患者受伤并改善预后。可穿戴传感器在某些癫痫发作的自动检测方面显示出有前景的结果,但它们存在局限性,如患者耐受性、对新生儿不实用以及需要充电。基于非接触式视频和音频的技术已经出现,但缺乏对这些方法的全面文献综述。本综述性文献综述概述了基于视频和音频的癫痫发作检测,突出了它们的潜在益处和挑战。它涵盖了对相关文章的全面搜索和评估,总结了这些系统的方法和性能。本综述的主要目的是检查和分析现有研究,以识别模式和差距,并为未来的进展奠定基础。我们使用一套标准化的搜索标准筛选了7个数据库,以尽量减少任何可能遗漏的文章。对4487篇去重摘要进行了筛选,并缩小到34项研究,这些研究在设计、算法方法、检测的癫痫发作类型和性能指标方面各不相同。癫痫发作检测灵敏度范围从100%到0%,光流分析显示出最高灵敏度。所有纳入文章的特异性范围从97.7%到60%。虽然只有有限的研究报告了准确率,但使用基于Radon变换的双树复数小波系数技术报告的最高准确率为100%。基于视频和音频的工具为癫痫发作的检测和监测提供了新颖的非接触方法。现有研究在样本量、数据集多样性和标准化评估协议方面存在局限性,影响了结果的可推广性。需要未来的研究聚焦于具有多样数据集、标准化评估协议和一致报告指标的大规模调查。