South East Technological University, Carlow, Ireland.
Institute of Technology Carlow, Carlow, Ireland.
Am J Mens Health. 2024 Nov-Dec;18(6):15579883241299353. doi: 10.1177/15579883241299353.
Stigma surrounding mental health, particularly among men, remains a significant barrier to men engaging with support services for their mental health. Despite increasing evidence of interventions targeting different aspects of stigma reduction, there is a notable gap in the literature concerning male-specific mental health stigma reduction interventions and on the underlying behavior change techniques (BCTs) used to reduce stigma. The purpose of this review is to synthesize the evidence relating to the impact of mental health stigma reduction interventions among men and to explore the underlying BCTs associated with each intervention. The review was restricted to empirical research reporting on interventions targeting mental health stigma in male-dominated populations. The quality appraisal was conducted using the Mixed Methods Analysis Tool and a narrative synthesis was conducted. Fourteen articles reporting on 11 interventions were included for review, while 20 outcome measures were used. Perceived public stigma attracted the largest number of interventions with a lesser focus on self or personal stigma. Nineteen BCTs were identified across the interventions with information about health consequences and self-monitoring of behavior being the most common followed by credible source, social contact, and behavior practice/rehearsal. This is discussed in relation to the wider literature. The methodological issues highlighted in the articles limit the conclusions and recommendations that can be drawn from the review. Recommendations for further research include standardizing the scales used in stigma measurement, in-depth reporting of intervention descriptions, and greater use of theory to guide intervention development.
心理健康方面的污名化问题,尤其是在男性中,仍然是男性寻求心理健康支持服务的一个重大障碍。尽管针对减少污名化的不同方面的干预措施已经有了越来越多的证据,但在针对男性特定心理健康污名化干预措施以及用于减少污名化的潜在行为改变技术(BCTs)方面,文献中仍存在明显的空白。本综述的目的是综合与男性心理健康污名化干预措施的影响相关的证据,并探讨与每个干预措施相关的潜在 BCTs。本综述仅限于针对男性主导人群的心理健康污名化干预措施的实证研究。使用混合方法分析工具进行质量评估,并进行叙述性综合分析。共有 14 篇报告针对男性主导人群的心理健康污名化干预措施的文章被纳入综述,共使用了 20 个结果测量指标。感知到的公众污名吸引了最多的干预措施,而对自我或个人污名的关注较少。在这些干预措施中确定了 19 个 BCTs,其中涉及健康后果和行为自我监测的信息最为常见,其次是可信来源、社会联系和行为实践/排练。这在更广泛的文献中进行了讨论。文章中强调的方法学问题限制了从综述中得出的结论和建议。进一步研究的建议包括标准化污名化测量中使用的量表、更深入地报告干预措施描述以及更多地使用理论来指导干预措施的发展。