Lead Engineer, Quest Global Engineering Services Pvt. Ltd., Hyderabad, India.
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Sri Sivasubramaniya Nadar College of Engineering, Kalavakkam, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, 603110, India.
J Mater Sci Mater Med. 2024 Nov 22;35(1):69. doi: 10.1007/s10856-024-06842-7.
Stainless steel and titanium-based alloys have been the gold standard when it comes to permanent implants and magnesium-based alloys have been the best option for bioresorbable alloys. Ti-6Al-4V, Ti-64, with its 110 GPa Young's Modulus is the most commonly employed alloy to manufacture biomedical implants used for treatment of fractures of skeleton. Recently, researchers have developed a new low-cost and toxic Vanadium-free alternative to this alloy, Ti-3Mo-0.5Fe at.%, namely TMF8. This alloy has a 25% lesser Young's Modulus compared to Ti-6Al-4V and also demonstrated acceptable mechanical properties while possessing better cell proliferation results. The lower Young's Modulus can aid in lowering stress shielding effects while its cytocompatibility could enhance healing. This work, therefore, tries to use finite element analyses to compare these two alloys (Ti-64 and TMF8) from a practical structural point of view to analyse the advantages and disadvantages of this new alloy and how a low-cost biocompatible alternative (TMF8) can actually prove to be a more viable option. The analyses confirm that TMF8 shows almost similar biomechanics performance to Ti-64 alloy (and in acceptable range) in bone plate fixation of mandibular angular fracture treatment.
不锈钢和钛基合金一直是永久性植入物的金标准,而镁基合金则是生物可吸收合金的最佳选择。Ti-6Al-4V、Ti-64,其杨氏模量为 110GPa,是最常用于制造用于治疗骨骼骨折的生物医学植入物的合金。最近,研究人员开发了一种新的低成本、无毒性的替代这种合金的方法,即 Ti-3Mo-0.5Fe(at.%),即 TMF8。与 Ti-6Al-4V 相比,这种合金的杨氏模量降低了 25%,同时还具有可接受的机械性能,并且具有更好的细胞增殖效果。较低的杨氏模量有助于降低应力屏蔽效应,而其细胞相容性可以促进愈合。因此,这项工作试图从实际的结构角度使用有限元分析来比较这两种合金(Ti-64 和 TMF8),分析这种新合金的优缺点,以及这种低成本的生物相容性替代物(TMF8)如何能成为更可行的选择。分析结果证实,在治疗下颌角骨折的骨板固定中,TMF8 显示出与 Ti-64 合金几乎相似的生物力学性能(在可接受范围内)。