Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, School of Public Health, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, Kumasi, Ghana.
Christian Health Association of Ghana, Accra, Ghana.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2024 Nov 22;24(1):1449. doi: 10.1186/s12913-024-11930-z.
Advances in health and technology have reduced HIV to a more manageable communicable disease. Yet, stigma and discrimination against people with HIV remain critical barriers to ending the pandemic by 2030. Due to limited literature on stigma and discrimination in Ghana, we aimed to assess the experiences and predictors of stigma among PWH seeking healthcare in selected health facilities.
This convergent parallel mixed-methods study involved 420 people with HIV responding to a quantitative survey and 25 PWH participating in qualitative interviews (9 in-depth interviews and 16 in focus group discussions). Respondents were recruited through systematic and purposive sampling techniques for the quantitative and qualitative aspects, respectively. Quantitative data were analyzed using Stata/SE version 16.0, with logistic regression models fitted to measure associations between predictor variables and experienced stigma. Qualitative data were analyzed thematically using NVivo software, employing an inductive approach.
Of the 420 participants, 58 (13.8%) reported ever experiencing stigma due to their HIV status. Among those who experienced stigma, 44 (75.9%) reported stigma in their communities, 24 (41.4%) in their homes, 15 (25.9%) at their workplaces, and 13 (22.4%) at health facilities. The most common forms of stigma were being gossiped about (26.0%), verbal insults/harassment (15.2%), and physical assault (8.3%). Qualitative findings corroborated these experiences, revealing impacts on healthcare access, social relationships, and mental health. Females (aOR = 13.10, 95% CI: 1.64-104.55) and persons with TB-HIV co-infection (aOR = 20.53, 95% CI: 3.28-128.56) had greater odds of experiencing stigma. PWH who were self-employed had lower odds of experiencing stigma at the HIV clinic (aOR = 0.07, 95% CI: 0.01-0.53, p = 0.009).
Experienced stigma ranged from low to moderate in different settings, with communities being the most common location. We observed differences in stigma experienced among PWH based on gender, employment status, and TB co-infection. These findings suggest a need for targeted, context-specific interventions to reduce HIV-related stigma in Ghana, with a particular focus on community-level interventions.
健康和技术的进步已经将 HIV 降低为一种更易于管理的传染病。然而,对 HIV 感染者的污名和歧视仍然是 2030 年终结艾滋病大流行的关键障碍。由于加纳有关污名和歧视的文献有限,我们旨在评估在选定的卫生机构中寻求医疗保健的 HIV 感染者经历污名和歧视的情况及其预测因素。
这项汇聚平行混合方法研究涉及 420 名 HIV 感染者,他们对定量调查做出了回应,并对 25 名 HIV 感染者进行了定性访谈(9 次深入访谈和 16 次焦点小组讨论)。分别通过系统抽样和目的抽样技术招募受访者进行定量和定性部分。使用 Stata/SE 版本 16.0 分析定量数据,并使用逻辑回归模型来衡量预测变量与经历的污名之间的关联。使用 NVivo 软件对定性数据进行主题分析,采用归纳方法。
在 420 名参与者中,有 58 名(13.8%)因 HIV 状况而经历过污名。在经历过污名的人中,有 44 人(75.9%)在社区中经历过污名,24 人(41.4%)在家中经历过污名,15 人(25.9%)在工作场所经历过污名,13 人(22.4%)在医疗机构中经历过污名。最常见的污名形式是被八卦(26.0%)、言语侮辱/骚扰(15.2%)和身体攻击(8.3%)。定性研究结果证实了这些经历,揭示了对医疗保健获取、社会关系和心理健康的影响。女性(aOR=13.10,95%CI:1.64-104.55)和结核病合并 HIV 感染的人(aOR=20.53,95%CI:3.28-128.56)经历污名的可能性更大。自营职业者在 HIV 诊所经历污名的可能性较低(aOR=0.07,95%CI:0.01-0.53,p=0.009)。
在不同环境中,经历的污名程度从低到中不等,社区是最常见的地点。我们观察到基于性别、就业状况和结核病合并感染的 HIV 感染者经历的污名存在差异。这些发现表明,需要针对加纳的情况制定有针对性的、具体的干预措施,以减少与 HIV 相关的污名,特别注重社区层面的干预措施。