Faculty of Medicine and Health, School of Public Health, The University of Sydney, Rm 127A Edward Ford Building A27, Camperdown, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
Wiser Healthcare research collaboration, Sydney, Australia.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2024 Nov 25;24(1):1457. doi: 10.1186/s12913-024-11903-2.
Clinical care contributes to at least 50% of the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of healthcare. This includes the 40% of healthcare that is harmful or low value, adding avoidable emissions without improving health or quality of care. Clinicians are well-placed to mitigate emissions associated with the provision of clinical care. This study aimed to explore clinicians' views on a new construct we have termed 'carbon health literacy' to understand how knowledge, skills and capacities related to the emissions of clinical care has application in clinical practice.
Qualitative interviews were conducted between August 2022 and February 2023 with clinicians from Australia (n = 15) and Canada (n = 13). Clinicians with an interest in climate change and healthcare sustainability were sampled from a variety of clinical specialty areas, such as primary care, nursing, anaesthetics, and emergency. Clinicians were recruited through advertising on social media and via professional networks. A pre-piloted interview schedule was used to guide the interviews. Interviews were audio recorded, transcribed verbatim and analysed using framework analysis.
Participants viewed carbon health literacy as an increasingly important skill for clinicians to have or acquire, though they reported that the level of carbon health literacy and knowledge needed varies by job roles, clinical specialty areas, and individual capacity to generate healthcare system change. Many clinicians reported implementing strategies to mitigate their work-related GHG emissions, such as reducing waste or choosing lower carbon commuting options. There was limited awareness of reducing low-value care as a strategy to decrease emissions. All participants had encountered barriers to providing low-carbon care, including managing patient expectations, inadequate training and information, and limited capacity to generate system change in their organisational roles.
To support the delivery of high value low carbon healthcare, work is needed to build the carbon health literacy of clinicians and remove other barriers currently impeding their capacity to practice and promote sustainable clinical care.
临床护理至少占医疗保健温室气体(GHG)排放量的 50%。这包括 40%对患者健康或护理质量没有益处或价值较低的医疗护理,在没有改善健康或护理质量的情况下增加了可避免的排放。临床医生有能力减轻与提供临床护理相关的排放。本研究旨在探讨临床医生对我们提出的一个新概念“碳健康素养”的看法,以了解与临床护理排放相关的知识、技能和能力在临床实践中的应用。
2022 年 8 月至 2023 年 2 月,我们对来自澳大利亚(n=15)和加拿大(n=13)的临床医生进行了定性访谈。我们从各种临床专业领域(如初级保健、护理、麻醉和急诊)中招募了对气候变化和医疗保健可持续性感兴趣的临床医生。通过在社交媒体上做广告和通过专业网络招募临床医生。使用预试验访谈计划来指导访谈。访谈进行了录音、逐字记录,并使用框架分析进行了分析。
参与者认为碳健康素养是临床医生需要具备或获得的一项越来越重要的技能,但他们报告说,碳健康素养和所需的知识水平因工作角色、临床专业领域以及个人产生医疗系统变革的能力而异。许多临床医生报告实施了减少与工作相关的温室气体排放的策略,例如减少浪费或选择碳排放量较低的通勤方式。减少低价值护理作为减少排放的策略的意识有限。所有参与者都遇到了提供低碳护理的障碍,包括管理患者的期望、培训和信息不足,以及在其组织角色中产生系统变革的能力有限。
为了支持提供高价值低碳医疗保健,需要努力提高临床医生的碳健康素养,并消除当前阻碍他们实践和促进可持续临床护理能力的其他障碍。