Department of Political Science, Aarhus University, Aarhus 8000, Denmark.
Centre for the Experimental-Philosophical Study of Discrimination, Department of Political Science, Aarhus University, Aarhus 8000, Denmark.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2024 Dec 3;121(49):e2404313121. doi: 10.1073/pnas.2404313121. Epub 2024 Nov 25.
In Europe, the tendency among immigrants and descendants to seek out and interact with other coethnics has raised concern for their integration as it can reduce contact with the ethnic majority. Though policymakers implement large-scale integration programs to counteract these trends, it remains empirically and theoretically ambiguous whether exposure to coethnic peers impedes integration, and causal evidence is more limited for the growing population of migrant children. In this article, I use high-quality Danish administrative panel data over 28 y to investigate whether the ethnic composition experienced in childhood among immigrants and descendants with a non-EU background affects a core behavioral indicator of integration: naturalization. To isolate the causal effect of the childhood ethnic composition, I use the quasi-experimental assignment of siblings into different school grades in the same school. I find that being exposed to coethnic peers in the school grade the probability of naturalizing later in life. The main explanation is that exposure to some coethnic peers improves academic skills which are positively correlated with citizenship acquisition. These findings demonstrate the causal importance of non-EU migrant children's social environment for their later integration into the national community showing that the modest presence of coethnic peers can be a precondition for, not a barrier to, integration.
在欧洲,移民和移民后代倾向于寻找和与其他同族裔互动,这引起了人们对他们融入社会的担忧,因为这会减少他们与多数族裔的接触。尽管政策制定者实施了大规模的融入计划来应对这些趋势,但接触同族裔同龄人是否会阻碍融入社会,在经验和理论上仍然存在不确定性,而且对于越来越多的移民儿童来说,因果证据更为有限。在本文中,我利用丹麦高质量的行政面板数据,在 28 年的时间跨度内,研究了具有非欧盟背景的移民和移民后代在童年时期经历的族裔构成是否会影响融入社会的一个核心行为指标:入籍。为了隔离童年族裔构成的因果效应,我利用兄弟姐妹在同一所学校的不同年级的准实验分配。我发现,在学校年级中接触到同族裔同龄人会降低一个人以后入籍的概率。主要的解释是,接触到一些同族裔同龄人可以提高学术技能,而这些技能与获得公民身份呈正相关。这些发现表明,非欧盟移民儿童的社会环境对他们以后融入国家社区具有重要的因果意义,这表明少量的同族裔同龄人可以成为融入社会的前提,而不是障碍。