Department of Economics, Uppsala University, 751 20 Uppsala, Sweden.
Immigration Policy Lab, Stanford University and ETH Zurich, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2019 Aug 13;116(33):16280-16285. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1820345116. Epub 2019 Jul 29.
There is widespread concern in Europe and other refugee-receiving continents that living in an enclave of coethnics hinders refugees' economic and social integration. Several European governments have adopted policies to geographically disperse refugees. While many theoretical arguments and descriptive studies analyze the impact of spatially concentrated ethnic networks on immigrant integration, there is limited causal evidence that sheds light on the efficacy of these policies. We provide evidence by studying the economic integration of refugees in Switzerland, where some refugees are assigned to live in a specific location upon arrival and, by law, are not permitted to relocate during the first 5 y. Leveraging this exogenous placement mechanism, we find that refugees assigned to locations with many conationals are more likely to enter the labor market. This benefit is most pronounced about 3 y after arrival and weakens somewhat with longer residency. In addition, we find that, among refugees employed by the same company, a high proportion share nationality, ethnicity, or language, which suggests that ethnic residential networks transmit information about employment opportunities. Together, these findings contribute to our understanding of the importance of ethnic networks for facilitating refugee integration, and they have implications for the design of refugee allocation policies.
在欧洲和其他难民接收大陆,人们普遍担心生活在同族聚居区会阻碍难民的经济和社会融合。一些欧洲政府已经采取了政策,将难民在地理上分散开。虽然许多理论观点和描述性研究分析了空间集中的族裔网络对移民融入的影响,但很少有因果证据能说明这些政策的效果。我们通过研究瑞士难民的经济融合情况提供了证据,在瑞士,一些难民抵达后被分配到特定地点居住,并且在头 5 年内法律上不允许搬迁。利用这种外生的安置机制,我们发现被分配到有很多同胞的地方的难民更有可能进入劳动力市场。这种好处在抵达后约 3 年最为明显,随着居住时间的延长而有所减弱。此外,我们发现,在同一家公司受雇的难民中,有很高比例的人具有相同的国籍、族裔或语言,这表明族裔居住网络传递了有关就业机会的信息。总之,这些发现有助于我们理解族裔网络对于促进难民融合的重要性,并且对难民分配政策的设计具有启示意义。