Department of Social and Cultural Sciences, Marquette University, United States.
Canada Research Chair in Migration and Care, Carleton University, Ottawa, Canada; Departments of Political Science, Sociology and Anthropology, and Institute of African Studies, Carleton University, Ottawa, Canada.
J Aging Stud. 2024 Dec;71:101276. doi: 10.1016/j.jaging.2024.101276. Epub 2024 Oct 19.
The Aging Enterprise was first coined by Carol Estes to critique the hegemony of a gerontological discourse and policy in the United States in the 1970s. These policy interventions seemed to be serving the needs of policy-makers and aging professionals, rather than those of older adults. More recently she wrote on how these interventions limited the possibilities of the gerontological imagination and focused attention on "old age" as a social problem. This paper builds on her work and that of Lawrence Cohen to examine the reach of the Aging Enterprise in Ghana, a country with limited state investments in aging. Bringing together two research projects, we are able to make our argument through an examination of aging policy and interventions in the public and private sectors, including across academic institutions, NGOs, churches, and markets. In our analysis, we propose the term age enterprising instead of the Aging Enterprise for three reasons. One, the discourse which situates old age as a problem has not been fully imported to Ghana, but instead becomes adapted to local ways that aging is constructed as a problem. Second, the discourses of age enterprises should not be taken at face value, as their projects can often fail, especially in the short run. Finally, we see a mix of different age enterprises which do not concatenate to create a monolithic force, but which diverge in key ways, thus creating a much more contingent and contradictory set of discourses around aging.
《老龄化企业》最初由卡罗尔·埃斯特斯(Carol Estes)提出,以批评 20 世纪 70 年代美国老年学话语和政策的霸权。这些政策干预似乎符合政策制定者和老龄化专业人士的需求,而不是老年人的需求。最近,她还写道,这些干预措施如何限制了老年学想象力的可能性,并将注意力集中在“老年”作为一个社会问题上。本文以她的作品以及劳伦斯·科恩(Lawrence Cohen)的作品为基础,考察了老龄化企业在加纳的影响力,加纳在老龄化方面的国家投资有限。我们汇集了两个研究项目,通过考察公共和私营部门的老龄化政策和干预措施,包括学术机构、非政府组织、教堂和市场,来论证我们的观点。在我们的分析中,我们提出了“年龄创业”一词而不是“老龄化企业”,原因有三。首先,将老年视为问题的话语并没有完全传入加纳,而是被适应当地将老龄化视为问题的方式。其次,不应轻信年龄企业的话语,因为它们的项目往往会失败,尤其是在短期内。最后,我们看到了不同的年龄企业,它们并没有串联成一股强大的力量,而是在关键方面存在分歧,从而在老龄化问题上形成了一套更加偶然和矛盾的话语。