Hervik Stein Egil Kolderup, Hervik Astrid Kolderup, Thoresen Trine, Thurston Miranda
Faculty of Humanities, Sports and Educational Science, University of South-Eastern Norway - Campus Vestfold, Horten, Norway.
Faculty of Social and Health Sciences, Inland Norway University of Applied Sciences, Elverum, Norway.
Int J Prison Health (2024). 2025 Mar 19;21(1):42-54. doi: 10.1108/IJOPH-05-2024-0026.
A settings-based approach to health promotion emphasizes everyday environments in shaping health. Prisons are, therefore, potentially important arenas for health promotion. However, the inherent restriction of prisoner agency presents a fundamental challenge in this regard. There is a gap in qualitative research on prisoners' perspectives on health-related topics and a need for greater understanding of health promotion within prisons. This study aims to explore male prisoners' experiences of a Norwegian low-security prison as a setting for health promotion.
DESIGN/METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: This study was conducted in Forest Prison, a Norwegian low-security facility for 125 male prisoners. The prison offers various amenities and activities to prepare inmates for reintegration into society. The research used semi-structured interviews with 20 diverse prisoners. Interviews were transcribed and analyzed using Gale 's framework method.
This study revealed varied prisoner perspectives on Forest Prison as a setting for health promotion. In prisoners' talk, the importance of agency was evident. Restricted agency triggered negative emotions and distrust, while extended agency fostered trust and wellbeing. Although Forest Prison provides a considerable degree of agency, some prisoners did not fully benefit from this agentic context because of disparities in resources.
ORIGINALITY/VALUE: Initiatives across three areas of action will strengthen Forest Prison as a setting for health promotion: extending agency, empowering prisoners and developing a prison culture with positive social relationships, effective communication and information flow. The findings of this study provide theoretical insights beyond the specific context, which can serve as a basis for developing prisons as health promoting settings.
基于环境的健康促进方法强调日常环境对健康的塑造作用。因此,监狱有可能成为健康促进的重要场所。然而,囚犯行动能力的内在限制在这方面构成了一项根本性挑战。关于囚犯对健康相关话题的看法的定性研究存在空白,并且需要更深入地了解监狱中的健康促进情况。本研究旨在探讨挪威一所低戒备监狱作为健康促进场所时男性囚犯的经历。
设计/方法/途径:本研究在森林监狱开展,这是一所挪威的低戒备监狱,关押着125名男性囚犯。该监狱提供各种便利设施和活动,帮助囚犯为重新融入社会做好准备。研究采用半结构化访谈,对象为20名不同的囚犯。访谈内容进行了转录,并使用盖尔的框架方法进行分析。
本研究揭示了囚犯对森林监狱作为健康促进场所的不同看法。在囚犯的交谈中,行动能力的重要性显而易见。行动能力受限引发负面情绪和不信任,而行动能力得到拓展则能促进信任和幸福感。尽管森林监狱提供了相当程度的行动能力,但由于资源差异,一些囚犯并未充分受益于这种行动能力环境。
原创性/价值:在三个行动领域采取的举措将加强森林监狱作为健康促进场所的作用:拓展行动能力、增强囚犯权能以及培育一种具有积极社会关系、有效沟通和信息流的监狱文化。本研究的结果提供了超越特定背景的理论见解,可为将监狱发展成为促进健康场所提供依据。