Raupach Tobias
Institut für Medizindidaktik, Universitätsklinikum Bonn, Venusberg-Campus 1, 53127, Bonn, Deutschland.
Medizinische Klinik und Poliklinik II - Herzzentrum, Universitätsklinikum Bonn, Bonn, Deutschland.
Herzschrittmacherther Elektrophysiol. 2025 Mar;36(1):91-95. doi: 10.1007/s00399-024-01057-3. Epub 2024 Dec 2.
In order to achieve favorable learning outcomes in medical students and residents, the development of educational interventions should be guided by specific principles. This article presents readers with a short summary of Kern's six-step approach to curriculum development before discussing results of medical education research with a focus on ECG teaching. A number of consecutive studies concluded that the choice of instructional format is less important for student learning outcome than examination consequences. Thus, if the final examination is summative (i.e., graded), students achieve higher scores regardless of the instructional method employed-even in the absence of formal teaching. Formative examinations are associated with considerably worse learning outcomes; however, they facilitate the detection of differences in effectiveness between various instructional formats. Follow-up data indicate that the loss of ECG interpretation skills is greater following a summative exam compared with a formative exam. In summary, while summative exams result in a short-term performance increase as they create a strong incentive to learn, they do not guarantee superior long-term retention. This begs the question which learning objectives can and should actually be covered in undergraduate and continuing medical education. The article concludes with a set of recommendations for the development of teaching interventions on heart rhythm disorders.
为了让医学生和住院医师取得良好的学习成果,教育干预措施的制定应遵循特定原则。本文在讨论以心电图教学为重点的医学教育研究结果之前,向读者简要介绍了克恩课程开发六步法。一系列连贯的研究得出结论,教学形式的选择对学生学习成果的重要性低于考试结果。因此,如果期末考试是总结性的(即评分的),无论采用何种教学方法,学生都会取得更高的分数——即使没有正式教学。形成性考试与明显更差的学习成果相关;然而,它们有助于发现各种教学形式在有效性方面的差异。后续数据表明,与形成性考试相比,总结性考试后心电图解读技能的丧失更为严重。总之,虽然总结性考试会因创造强大的学习动力而导致短期成绩提高,但它们并不能保证长期的优异记忆效果。这就引出了一个问题,即本科医学教育和继续医学教育中实际可以且应该涵盖哪些学习目标。文章最后针对心律失常教学干预措施的开发提出了一系列建议。