Rodgers Zoe Jane, Bejmert Karolina, Chung Tiani, Furness James, Abery Philip, Kemp-Smith Kevin, Taylor Nicholas, Bruce Kimberley Casey, Snelling Peter James
Physiotherapy Department, Bond University, Gold Coast, Queensland, Australia.
Emergency Department, Canberra Hospital, Canberra, Australian Capital Territory, Australia.
Emerg Med Australas. 2025 Feb;37(1):e14537. doi: 10.1111/1742-6723.14537. Epub 2024 Dec 3.
The current ANZCOR guidelines for first aid management of life-threatening bleeding from a limb, where bleeding cannot be controlled with direct pressure, recommends the use of an arterial tourniquet. However, tourniquets required specialised training and equipment, which may not be accessible in all emergencies. This systematic review evaluated the effectiveness of arterial pressure point techniques (APPT) as a first aid measure for controlling life-threatening, non-compressible bleeding from limbs and anatomical junctions. A comprehensive literature search was conducted following the PRISMA guidelines. The search was used in five databases: PubMed, CINAHL, SportDiscuss, Proquest Central and Embase. Eligible studies included adult participants in and out of hospital settings, focusing on extremities and junctional areas. Studies assessing APPT alone or compared with other first aid techniques were included. The review included nine quasi-experimental articles, with eight having low levels of evidence. Although most reported high success rates (87.5-100%) for APPT achieving blood flow cessation, its effectiveness compared to alternative methods, such as arterial tourniquets, remains inconclusive because of methodological heterogeneity and differing success benchmarks. APPT shows promise in external haemorrhage control. Additional research with higher levels of evidence, standardised protocols and larger sample sizes is needed. Investigation in real-world scenarios is crucial to compare methods like tourniquets. Future research will determine APPT's effectiveness and its potential role as a bridging technique before tourniquet application or medical assistance.
目前,澳新复甦委员会(ANZCOR)针对肢体危及生命的出血(即无法通过直接压迫控制出血)的急救管理指南,建议使用动脉止血带。然而,止血带需要专门的培训和设备,在所有紧急情况下可能无法获取。本系统评价评估了动脉压点技术(APPT)作为控制肢体和解剖连接处危及生命的不可压缩出血的急救措施的有效性。按照PRISMA指南进行了全面的文献检索。检索使用了五个数据库:PubMed、CINAHL、SportDiscuss、Proquest Central和Embase。符合条件的研究包括在医院内外的成年参与者,重点关注四肢和连接区域。纳入了单独评估APPT或与其他急救技术比较的研究。该评价纳入了九篇半实验性文章,其中八篇证据水平较低。尽管大多数报告称APPT实现血流停止的成功率较高(87.5 - 100%),但由于方法学异质性和不同的成功基准,与动脉止血带等替代方法相比,其有效性仍不确定。APPT在控制外出血方面显示出前景。需要更多具有更高证据水平、标准化方案和更大样本量的研究。在现实场景中进行调查对于比较止血带等方法至关重要。未来的研究将确定APPT的有效性及其在应用止血带或医疗援助之前作为过渡技术的潜在作用。