Amode Olatunde A, Negedu Omaye V, Joseph Jessica T, Igbokwe Uchenna, Adekeye Olajumoke, Oyedele Damilola K, Salele Hadiza, Ameyan Lola, Afolabi Kayode, Fasawe Olufunke, Wiwa Owens
Sexual Reproductive, Maternal and Newborn Care Program, Clinton Health Access Initiative, Minna, Nigeria.
Sexual Reproductive Health Program, Clinton Health Access Initiative, Maitama, Abuja, Nigeria.
Int J MCH AIDS. 2024 Sep 23;13(Suppl 1):S38-S45. doi: 10.25259/IJMA_1_2024. eCollection 2024 Sep.
The burden of maternal mortality attributable to postpartum hemorrhage (PPH) remains high in Nigeria. Currently, oxytocin, and misoprostol, which are largely of suboptimal quality, are used for PPH prevention and treatment. Heat-stable carbetocin (HSC) is a viable uterotonic option for PPH prevention in a setting like Nigeria where compromised supply and cold chain systems result in the preponderance of poor-quality oxytocin and suboptimal PPH management. It is crucial to understand how healthcare providers (HCPs) accept and use HSC for PPH prevention, and what factors encourage correct uterotonic usage in health facilities, given PPH's ongoing public health challenge. This study aims to elucidate the current prophylactic use of HSC, oxytocin, and misoprostol in secondary and tertiary public health facilities while assessing HSC acceptability to clinicians and establishing factors that enable the appropriate use of uterotonics in health facilities.
Descriptive analysis conducted on quantitative data from patient chart reviews, HCP interviews and assessment, and facility assessment using Stata 15 and Microsoft Excel are presented as counts and percentages, while qualitative data from key informant interviews and in-depth interviews are coded and analyzed using NVivo. The findings from 18 publicly owned secondary and tertiary healthcare facilities across Kano, Lagos, and Niger states in Nigeria were interpreted according to thematic areas. Health facilities selection criteria were high volume of deliveries (≥30 deliveries per month), accessible location, availability of trained HCPs (specifically doctors, nurses, and midwives), and willingness to participate in the study.
HSC was administered prophylactically in 10,284 (56%) of 18,364 deliveries, with a total of 148 (0.8%) women developing PPH. Approximately 76% of HCPs preferred HSC for PPH prevention compared to other available uterotonics, with clinical guidance from senior HCPs (76%), in-service training (76%), mentoring (84%), and supportive supervision (75%) contributing significantly to the choice and practice of uterotonics use by HCPs.
HSC, a thermostable analog of oxytocin, holds the potential to prevent PPH without the added cost of administering additional uterotonics and interventions. The introduction of HSC requires concerted procurement and capacity-building efforts to create an enabling environment for scale-up. HSC is non-inferior to oxytocin in preventing PPH, has few side effects compared to misoprostol or oxytocin-misoprostol combination, and more cost-effective when compared with the other three uterotonics. Although the geographical scope of our study is only three states in Nigeria, the preponderance of suboptimal uterotonics across the country makes our findings applicable to the whole country and other low- and middle-income countries with similar challenges.
在尼日利亚,产后出血(PPH)导致的孕产妇死亡负担仍然很高。目前,质量大多欠佳的缩宫素和米索前列醇被用于预防和治疗PPH。在尼日利亚这样的环境中,供应和冷链系统不完善导致劣质缩宫素占主导,PPH管理欠佳,热稳定的卡贝缩宫素(HSC)是预防PPH的一种可行的宫缩剂选择。鉴于PPH持续构成公共卫生挑战,了解医疗服务提供者(HCPs)如何接受和使用HSC预防PPH,以及哪些因素鼓励在医疗机构正确使用宫缩剂至关重要。本研究旨在阐明二级和三级公共卫生机构中HSC、缩宫素和米索前列醇的当前预防性使用情况,同时评估临床医生对HSC的可接受性,并确定在医疗机构中促使宫缩剂恰当使用的因素。
对来自患者病历审查、HCP访谈与评估以及机构评估的定量数据进行描述性分析,使用Stata 15和Microsoft Excel以计数和百分比形式呈现,而来自关键 informant访谈和深入访谈的定性数据使用NVivo进行编码和分析。根据主题领域对尼日利亚卡诺州、拉各斯州和尼日尔州18家公立二级和三级医疗机构的研究结果进行解读。医疗机构选择标准为分娩量高(每月≥30次分娩)、位置便利、有经过培训的HCPs(特别是医生、护士和助产士)以及愿意参与研究。
在18364例分娩中的10284例(56%)中预防性使用了HSC,共有148例(0.8%)妇女发生PPH。与其他可用宫缩剂相比,约76%的HCPs更倾向于使用HSC预防PPH,高级HCPs的临床指导(76%)、在职培训(76%)、指导(84%)和支持性监督(75%)对HCPs选择和使用宫缩剂的实践有显著贡献。
HSC是缩宫素的热稳定类似物,有潜力预防PPH,且无需额外使用宫缩剂和干预措施的附加成本。引入HSC需要协同采购和能力建设努力,以创造扩大使用的有利环境。HSC在预防PPH方面不劣于缩宫素,与米索前列醇或缩宫素 - 米索前列醇联合使用相比副作用较少,与其他三种宫缩剂相比更具成本效益。尽管我们研究的地理范围仅为尼日利亚的三个州,但全国劣质宫缩剂占主导的情况使我们的研究结果适用于整个国家以及面临类似挑战的其他低收入和中等收入国家。