Bulloch Marissa, Olsen Jonathan R
School of Health and Wellbeing, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK.
MRC/CSO Social and Public Health Sciences Unit, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK.
Cities Health. 2024 Feb 29;8(6):1081-1093. doi: 10.1080/23748834.2024.2315804. eCollection 2024.
This study aimed to examine how young people subjectively perceive their local neighbourhoods and compare these perceptions with objective data regarding access to amenities aligned with features of the 20-minute neighbourhood (20MN) policy. Objective data (n:287 aged 12-18 years) were gathered through an online adaptation of the Place Standard Tool for Young People in Scotland. Subjective data concerning access to ten amenities in line with the 20MN concept, along with crime statistics, area-level deprivation and urbanicity were spatially linked. The association between perceptions of localities and factors such as gender, as well as both subjective and objective neighbourhood assessments were examined. Young people were most satisfied with nature and active travel in their local area. Conversely, their satisfaction was lowest for active travel to school. Rural young people were more dissatisfied with their localities. Agreement was observed between satisfaction with their 20 neighbourhoods and objective data indicating the presence of frequent public transportation, recreational spaces, and access to services. In conclusion, our study highlights the importance of amenities in healthy urban planning, showing a positive impact on young people's perceptions. Additionally, we uncover a connection between crime perceptions and area-level crime variables, potentially influencing health outcomes.
本研究旨在探讨年轻人如何主观地看待他们所在的社区,并将这些看法与关于获得符合20分钟社区(20MN)政策特征的便利设施的客观数据进行比较。客观数据(n = 287,年龄在12至18岁之间)通过对苏格兰青少年版场所标准工具的在线改编收集。与20MN概念相符的十种便利设施的获取情况的主观数据,以及犯罪统计数据、地区层面的贫困程度和城市化程度在空间上进行了关联。研究了对社区的看法与性别等因素之间的关联,以及主观和客观的社区评估。年轻人对当地的自然环境和主动出行最为满意。相反,他们对上学的主动出行满意度最低。农村地区的年轻人对当地更为不满。在对其20分钟社区的满意度与表明存在频繁公共交通、休闲空间和服务获取情况的客观数据之间观察到了一致性。总之,我们的研究强调了便利设施在健康城市规划中的重要性,显示出对年轻人看法的积极影响。此外,我们发现了对犯罪的认知与地区层面犯罪变量之间的联系,这可能会影响健康结果。