Mizokami Fumihiro, Mizuno Tomohiro, Taguchi Rena, Nasu Izumi, Arai Sayaka, Higashi Keiichiro, Matsumoto Ayaka, Kamei Miwako, Kojima Taro, Sakai Takayoshi, Shibata Yuuka, Takeya Yasushi, Mogi Masaki, Yamada Shizuo, Akishita Masahiro
Department of Pharmacy, National Center for Geriatrics and Gerontology, Obu, Japan.
Department of Pharmacotherapeutics and Informatics, Fujita Health University School of Medicine, Toyoake, Japan.
Geriatr Gerontol Int. 2025 Jan;25(1):5-13. doi: 10.1111/ggi.15001. Epub 2024 Dec 5.
Anticholinergic burden, reflecting the cumulative impact of medications with anticholinergic properties, significantly predicts adverse drug reactions and geriatric syndromes in older adults. Although anticholinergic risk scales (ARS) have been developed and validated in various countries, none have been tailored specifically for Japan. The Japanese Anticholinergic Risk Scale (JARS) was developed to adapt the existing ARS frameworks to the Japanese context, considering unique medication profiles and cultural factors.
First, a systematic review was performed to follow the protocol registered in PROSPERO (CRD42017076510). A PubMed search from October 2017 to March 2023 was conducted to identify ARS publications post-September 2017. Based on two algorithms, average scores from the existing scores were used to develop JARS. The Delphi method, an expert consensus approach, was applied to determine the scores for medications that were not established by the algorithms. Sixteen articles identified in our systematic review contributed to JARS development. JARS categorizes 158 medications into three potency groups: 37 drugs scored as 3 (strong), 27 as 2 (moderate), and 94 as 1 (weak).
JARS, the newly developed ARS, could be a critical tool for anticholinergic burden assessment in older Japanese populations. Developed through a systematic review and Delphi-based expert consensus, it encompasses 158 medications, offering a comprehensive anticholinergic burden assessment. Future studies and updates should be conducted to improve the accuracy and clinical applicability of this scale. Geriatr Gerontol Int 2025; 25: 5-13.
抗胆碱能负担反映了具有抗胆碱能特性药物的累积影响,能显著预测老年人的药物不良反应和老年综合征。尽管抗胆碱能风险量表(ARS)已在多个国家开发并验证,但尚无专门针对日本的量表。日本抗胆碱能风险量表(JARS)的开发是为了使现有的ARS框架适应日本的情况,同时考虑到独特的用药情况和文化因素。
首先,按照在PROSPERO(CRD42017076510)注册的方案进行系统评价。对2017年10月至2023年3月期间的PubMed进行检索,以识别2017年9月之后发表的ARS相关文献。基于两种算法,利用现有评分的平均得分来开发JARS。采用德尔菲法(一种专家共识方法)来确定算法未确定的药物的评分。我们系统评价中确定的16篇文章为JARS的开发做出了贡献。JARS将158种药物分为三个效力组:37种药物评分为3(强效),27种评分为2(中效),94种评分为1(弱效)。
新开发的ARS——JARS,可能是评估日本老年人群抗胆碱能负担的关键工具。它通过系统评价和基于德尔菲法的专家共识开发而成,涵盖158种药物,提供了全面的抗胆碱能负担评估。未来应进行研究和更新,以提高该量表的准确性和临床适用性。《老年医学与老年病学国际杂志》2025年;25:5 - 13。