Gasparutto Xavier, Bonnefoy-Mazure Alice, Attias Michael, Turcot Katia, Armand Stéphane, Miozzari Hermès H
Kinesiology Laboratory, Geneva University Hospitals and University of Geneva, Geneva, Switzerland.
HES-SO University of Applied Sciences and Arts Western Switzerland, School of Health Sciences, Geneva, Switzerland.
PLoS One. 2024 Dec 5;19(12):e0314991. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0314991. eCollection 2024.
Total Knee Arthroplasty has well-established success in relieving knee pain and improving function but patients do not reach functional levels of control groups after surgery and 20% of patients remain unsatisfied. To understand the different patient profiles and develop patient-specific approaches of care, functional phenotypes based on knee biomechanics during gait have been evaluated. To widen the understanding of patient's function, it seems crucial to consider the gait devieations at the whole body level. Thus, this study aims at 1) assessing the impact of knee OA on full-body gait mechanics, 2) assessing whether potential deviations persist one year after TKA surgery, and 3) their potential impact on satisfaction. To that end, clinical gait analysis was performed before and one year after surgery for 100 patients planned for unilateral primary TKA, along with 32 healthy participants as control group. Patients were clustered by applying K-means algorithms on full-body kinematic features of gait before surgery. The knee was excluded from classification to focus on full-body kinematics. Differences between groups, with controls, as well as before and after surgery were evaluated for patients reported outcome measures, kinematic features, and spatio-temporal parameters. Three functional groups were identified. One low-functioning cluster with mostly elderly women showing significant functional improvement one year after surgery, and two high-functioning clusters differentiated by pelvis tilt (anteversion vs. retroversion), sagittal knee alignment (varus vs. neutral), and knee flexion during stance phase (flexum vs. extended) that showed limited improvement one year after surgery. Satisfaction rates were similar among clusters and mental scores improved for all clusters. High functioning patients may benefit from TKA, mostly due to pain reduction, but may not see significant improvement of their function, with no clear impact on satisfaction rate. On the contrary, patients with important functional limitation are more likely to improve both pain and functional outcomes.
全膝关节置换术在缓解膝关节疼痛和改善功能方面已取得了公认的成功,但患者术后并未达到对照组的功能水平,且20%的患者仍不满意。为了了解不同的患者特征并制定针对患者的个性化护理方法,基于步态期间膝关节生物力学的功能表型已得到评估。为了更全面地理解患者的功能,在全身水平上考虑步态偏差似乎至关重要。因此,本研究旨在:1)评估膝关节骨关节炎对全身步态力学的影响;2)评估全膝关节置换术(TKA)后一年潜在偏差是否持续存在;3)评估它们对满意度的潜在影响。为此,对100例计划进行单侧初次全膝关节置换术的患者在手术前和术后一年进行了临床步态分析,并以32名健康参与者作为对照组。通过对手术前步态的全身运动学特征应用K均值算法对患者进行聚类。分类时不考虑膝关节,以专注于全身运动学。对患者报告的结局指标、运动学特征和时空参数评估了组间差异、与对照组的差异以及手术前后的差异。确定了三个功能组。一个功能低下的聚类,主要是老年女性,术后一年显示出显著的功能改善;另外两个功能较高的聚类,通过骨盆倾斜(前倾与后倾)、矢状面膝关节对线(内翻与中立)以及站立期膝关节屈曲(屈曲与伸展)来区分,术后一年显示出有限的改善。各聚类之间的满意度相似,所有聚类的心理评分均有所改善。功能较高的患者可能从全膝关节置换术中获益,主要是由于疼痛减轻,但功能可能没有显著改善,对满意度没有明显影响。相反,功能有重要限制的患者更有可能在疼痛和功能结局方面得到改善。