Li Tongxin, Zhang Xiaofei, Wang Conghui, Tian Tian, Chi Jinghui, Zeng Min, Zhang Xiao, Wang Lili, Li Shen
Institute of Mental Health, Tianjin Anding Hospital, Mental Health Center of Tianjin Medical University, Tianjin, China; Brain Assessment & Intervention Laboratory, Tianjin Anding Hospital, Mental Health Center of Tianjin Medical University, Tianjin, China.
Department of Psychiatry, Tianjin Anding Hospital, Mental Health Center of Tianjin Medical University, Tianjin, China; Brain Assessment & Intervention Laboratory, Tianjin Anding Hospital, Mental Health Center of Tianjin Medical University, Tianjin, China.
J Psychiatr Res. 2025 Jan;181:225-236. doi: 10.1016/j.jpsychires.2024.11.065. Epub 2024 Nov 29.
Facial images have been shown to convey mental conditions as clinical symptoms. This study aimed to use facial images to detect patients with drug-naive schizophrenia (DN-SCZ) or chronic schizophrenia (C-SCZ) from healthy controls (HCs), and to investigate differences in facial expressions among these 3 groups, as well as relationships between facial expressions and psychiatric symptoms.
We recruited 45 DN-SCZ patients, 106 C-SCZ patients and 101 HCs for the study, and videotaped their facial expressions through a fixed experimental paradigm. The video data was converted to facial images and divided into two sets: one for training a group classification-convolutional neural network (CNN) with the classification of DN-SCZ patient, C-SCZ patient and HC as output, and the other for evaluating classification results of the group classification-CNN. Subsequently, we extracted and evaluated 300 labeled facial images for each basic facial expression. These labeled images were employed to train separate facial expression-CNNs for each group (DN-SCZ, C-SCZ, and HCs). All facial images from the videos were then processed by their facial expression-CNNs to output the most probable facial expressions. The psychiatric symptoms were assessed using the Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale. Statistical analyses were conducted on the predicted facial expressions to identify differences among the groups, and to examine relationships between the predicted facial expressions and the clinical data of DN/C-SCZ patients.
The group classification-CNN achieved an accuracy of 90.99% in correctly classifying participants based on facial images. The 3 facial expression-CNNs achieved accuracies of 95.95%, 87.23%, and 92.11% in predicting 8 basic facial expressions within the 3 groups. Facial images of HCs were rated higher in valence, arousal and attractiveness, but lower in deviation from normal face than those of DN/C-SCZ patients. Happy images of DN-SCZ patients were rated lower in valence and arousal than those of C-SCZ patients, while their angry images were rated higher in arousal, attractiveness and deviation from normal images than those of C-SCZ patients. Within the fixed experimental paradigm, DN-SCZ patients exhibited sadder, more surprised expressions, while displaying fewer happy, angry and disgusted expressions, statistical metrics of their fearful and angry expressions were correlated with their total positive symptom score and total general psychopathology score, respectively. C-SCZ patients exhibited happier, more content, angry and neutral expressions, while showing fewer surprised expressions, no significant relationships were observed between their facial expressions and clinical data.
Facial expressions can potentially serve as indicative signs for detecting DN-SCZ and C-SCZ patients. There are objective differences in certain facial expressions among the 3 groups, and certain facial expressions in DN-SCZ patients are associated with some of their psychiatric symptoms.
面部图像已被证明可作为临床症状传达精神状况。本研究旨在利用面部图像从健康对照者(HCs)中检测初发未用药精神分裂症(DN-SCZ)患者或慢性精神分裂症(C-SCZ)患者,并调查这三组之间面部表情的差异,以及面部表情与精神症状之间的关系。
我们招募了45例DN-SCZ患者、106例C-SCZ患者和101例HCs参与本研究,并通过固定的实验范式录制他们的面部表情。视频数据被转换为面部图像并分为两组:一组用于训练以DN-SCZ患者、C-SCZ患者和HC的分类为输出的组分类卷积神经网络(CNN),另一组用于评估组分类CNN的分类结果。随后,我们提取并评估了每种基本面部表情的300张带标签面部图像。这些带标签的图像被用于为每组(DN-SCZ、C-SCZ和HCs)训练单独的面部表情CNN。然后,视频中的所有面部图像都通过其面部表情CNN进行处理,以输出最可能的面部表情。使用阳性和阴性症状量表评估精神症状。对预测的面部表情进行统计分析,以确定组间差异,并检查预测的面部表情与DN/C-SCZ患者临床数据之间的关系。
组分类CNN在基于面部图像正确分类参与者方面的准确率达到90.99%。3个面部表情CNN在预测三组内的8种基本面部表情时的准确率分别为95.95%、87.23%和92.11%。HCs的面部图像在效价、唤醒度和吸引力方面得分较高,但在与正常面部的偏差方面得分低于DN/C-SCZ患者。DN-SCZ患者的快乐图像在效价和唤醒度方面的评分低于C-SCZ患者,而他们的愤怒图像在唤醒度、吸引力和与正常图像的偏差方面的评分高于C-SCZ患者。在固定的实验范式中,DN-SCZ患者表现出更悲伤、更惊讶的表情,而快乐、愤怒和厌恶的表情较少,他们恐惧和愤怒表情的统计指标分别与其总阳性症状评分和总一般精神病理学评分相关。C-SCZ患者表现出更快乐、更满足、愤怒和中性的表情,而惊讶的表情较少,他们的面部表情与临床数据之间未观察到显著关系。
面部表情有可能作为检测DN-SCZ和C-SCZ患者的指示性标志。三组之间某些面部表情存在客观差异,DN-SCZ患者的某些面部表情与其一些精神症状相关。