Faneli Adriano C, Amaral Dillan C, Cheidde Laura, Gonzales Luanna Guimarães A, Torres Rodrigo A, Souza Murilo B, Oliveira Ricardo D C
Medicine, BAHIANA - School of Medicine and Public Health, Salvador, BRA.
Medicine, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, BRA.
Cureus. 2024 Nov 4;16(11):e72965. doi: 10.7759/cureus.72965. eCollection 2024 Nov.
Background Medical school ophthalmology education is often insufficient for non-ophthalmologist physicians to achieve proficiency in managing ophthalmic cases. Objective This study evaluates learning during a clinical rotation in a Brazilian medical school that implemented a two-week ophthalmology rotation. Methods This quantitative and qualitative study involved all eligible students for the rotation. Two different questionnaires were administered before and after to assess knowledge, understanding, and problem-solving abilities in ophthalmology. Each questionnaire contained 11 theme-paired questions developed according to the International Council of Ophthalmology curriculum and guidelines for medical student education. The primary qualitative outcome was a 30% improvement in scores between the pre- and post-rotation tests, as defined by two ophthalmology professors who developed the questionnaire. Data was analyzed anonymously using STATA BE 18 software, and questionnaire reliability was measured using Kuder-Richardson Formula. Results Of the 69 eligible students, 36 (52.17%) completed both tests. The internal consistency of the pre-and post-rotation questionnaires was acceptable, with Kuder-Richardson Formula scores of 0.66 and 0.64, respectively. Although scores significantly improved from 6.97 pre-rotation to 7.72 post-rotation (p=0.01), the mean score only improved by 10.76%, falling short of the 30% target. Scores improved significantly in the Red Eye and Primary Care Attention from 0.49 to 0.78 (p<0.01), but decreased in Anatomy and Physiology of the Posterior Segment (from 0.80 to 0.67, p<0.01) and the Anatomy and Physiology of Extraocular Muscles (from 0.92 to 0.79, p=0.04). No statistically significant difference was observed in the Anatomy and Physiology of the Anterior Chamber. Conclusions This study concludes that undergraduate students learning during an ophthalmology rotation was unsatisfactory. However, this is an exploratory study; further research with a larger sample size is necessary.
背景 医学院校的眼科教育往往不足以让非眼科医生在处理眼科病例时达到熟练水平。目的 本研究评估巴西一所医学院校实施为期两周的眼科轮转期间的学习情况。方法 这项定量和定性研究涉及所有符合轮转条件的学生。在轮转前后分别发放两份不同的问卷,以评估眼科知识、理解能力和问题解决能力。每份问卷包含11对主题相关问题,这些问题是根据国际眼科理事会的课程和医学生教育指南编制的。主要定性结果是,由编制问卷的两位眼科教授定义为轮转前后测试分数提高30%。使用STATA BE 18软件对数据进行匿名分析,并使用库德-理查森公式测量问卷信度。结果 在69名符合条件的学生中,36名(52.17%)完成了两项测试。轮转前后问卷的内部一致性可以接受,库德-理查森公式得分分别为0.66和0.64。虽然分数从轮转前的6.97显著提高到轮转后的7.72(p = 0.01),但平均分仅提高了10.76%,未达到30%的目标。“红眼病和初级护理”部分的分数从0.49显著提高到0.78(p<0.01),但“眼后段解剖与生理”(从0.80降至0.67,p<0.01)和“眼外肌解剖与生理”(从0.92降至0.79,p = 0.04)部分的分数下降。前房解剖与生理部分未观察到统计学上的显著差异。结论 本研究得出结论,本科生在眼科轮转期间的学习情况不尽人意。然而,这是一项探索性研究;有必要进行更大样本量的进一步研究。