Muss Tessa E, Malphrus Elizabeth, Albano Nicholas, Kanchwala Suhail
From the Division of Plastic Surgery, Department of Surgery, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA.
Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open. 2024 Dec 6;12(12):e6342. doi: 10.1097/GOX.0000000000006342. eCollection 2024 Dec.
The complex skills required to perform microsurgery are primarily taught in the high-stakes environment of the operating room. However, learners would benefit from developing these abilities in lower-stakes environments beforehand, allowing them to focus on higher-level tasks intraoperatively. This article outlines available resources for developing microsurgical skills outside the operating room and evaluates their alignment with best practices for performance enhancement, thereby identifying ways to improve microsurgical education.
A systematic review and web search were performed in April 2024 to identify available microsurgical skills courses. Descriptive data were extracted from these resources, including course objectives, unique features, model used, and curriculum.
Literature and web search revealed 7 online video courses addressing microsurgical skill development. These had freely available multimedia content and used low-fidelity models with widely accessible materials. Six offered a curriculum. By contrast, 14 in-person flap and microsurgery courses in the United States were identified. These occurred over 2-5 days, cost thousands of dollars, and used high-fidelity models with guidance from experts. Finally, there were many simulation platforms ranging from low-fidelity synthetic models to cadaveric tissue to high-fidelity live animal models. These also encompassed technology-based practices such as virtual reality.
Compared with high-fidelity training, low-fidelity models are more affordable, are reusable, and allow for dedicated educational opportunities that are better aligned with best practices for knowledge and skill acquisition. Consequently, they have the potential to reach a broader range of trainees and accelerate the learning curve, and therefore should be integrated into every microsurgery training program.
进行显微外科手术所需的复杂技能主要是在手术室这种高风险环境中传授的。然而,学习者若能事先在风险较低的环境中培养这些能力,将受益匪浅,这样他们在手术中就能专注于更高层次的任务。本文概述了在手术室之外培养显微外科技能的可用资源,并评估它们与提高手术表现的最佳实践的契合度,从而找出改进显微外科技能培训的方法。
2024年4月进行了系统综述和网络搜索,以确定可用的显微外科技能课程。从这些资源中提取描述性数据,包括课程目标、独特特征、使用的模型和课程设置。
文献和网络搜索发现了7门针对显微外科技能培养的在线视频课程。这些课程有免费的多媒体内容,使用的是材料易于获取的低仿真模型。其中6门提供了课程设置。相比之下,在美国确定了14门现场皮瓣和显微外科课程。这些课程为期2至5天,费用高达数千美元,使用高仿真模型并由专家指导。最后,有许多模拟平台,从低仿真的合成模型到尸体组织,再到高仿真的活体动物模型。这些平台还包括虚拟现实等基于技术的实践。
与高仿真培训相比,低仿真模型更经济实惠、可重复使用,并能提供与知识和技能获取的最佳实践更契合的专门教育机会。因此,它们有可能惠及更广泛的学员群体并加速学习曲线,所以应纳入每个显微外科培训项目中。