Melamed Anna, Rocca-Ihenacho Lucia, Horn Anna, McCourt Christine, Rivers Frances, Daniele Marina Alice Sylvia
City University of London, London, UK.
University of the West of England, Bristol, UK.
Birth. 2025 Sep;52(3):491-502. doi: 10.1111/birt.12897. Epub 2024 Dec 9.
In UK maternity care, racialized women have worse experiences and clinical outcomes than White women. Midwife-led birth settings (MLBS), including home births and midwife-led units, both freestanding and alongside hospitals, are all available as choices for low-risk women in the UK. MLBS deliver optimal outcomes for low-risk women with uncomplicated pregnancies, including for racialized women, and can offer culturally specific care, possibly mitigating existing social inequalities. Evidence suggests that racialized women access MLBS less than White women.
To map existing literature on facilitators and barriers to accessing MLBS for racialized women and to identify emerging themes.
A scoping review of UK literature over the last 10 years using OVID, Ebsco Host, and gray literature. Search, selection, and data extraction were performed using PRISMA and JBI guidelines. Data were analyzed using inductive thematic analysis.
Fourteen articles met the inclusion criteria, only one addressing the research question directly and others containing some relevant material. Six themes were identified: admission criteria, information giving, the role of antenatal groups, bias and assumptions, beliefs about birth, and MLBS as empowering.
There is a lack of research on racialized women's access to MLBS. Community outreach, having midwifery services embedded in the community, defaulting to MLBS for women categorized as low risk, continuity of carer, and interventions achieving a reduction in care-giver bias may improve access and outcomes.
在英国的孕产妇护理中,与白人女性相比,有色人种女性的经历和临床结果更差。由助产士主导的分娩环境(MLBS),包括家庭分娩以及独立的和附属于医院的助产士主导单元,都是英国低风险女性可选择的分娩方式。MLBS能为怀孕情况简单的低风险女性,包括有色人种女性,带来最佳分娩结果,并且可以提供具有文化针对性的护理,有可能缓解现有的社会不平等现象。有证据表明,有色人种女性使用MLBS的比例低于白人女性。
梳理关于有色人种女性使用MLBS的促进因素和障碍的现有文献,并确定新出现的主题。
使用OVID、Ebsco Host以及灰色文献对过去10年的英国文献进行范围综述。按照PRISMA和JBI指南进行检索、筛选和数据提取。采用归纳主题分析法对数据进行分析。
14篇文章符合纳入标准,只有一篇直接涉及研究问题,其他文章包含一些相关材料。确定了六个主题:入院标准、信息提供、产前小组的作用、偏见与假设、对分娩的看法以及MLBS的赋权作用。
关于有色人种女性使用MLBS的研究较少。社区外展、在社区中提供助产服务、将低风险女性默认分配至MLBS、护理人员的连续性以及采取干预措施减少护理人员的偏见,可能会改善使用情况和分娩结果。