Hu Derek K, Pinto-Orellana Marco A, Rana Mandeep, Do Linda, Adams David J, Hussain Shaun A, Shrey Daniel W, Lopour Beth A
Department of Biomedical Engineering, University of California, Irvine, California, USA.
Department of Biomedical Engineering, California State University, Long Beach, California, USA.
Epilepsia. 2025 Feb;66(2):541-553. doi: 10.1111/epi.18211. Epub 2024 Dec 12.
The discovery and validation of electroencephalography (EEG) biomarkers often rely on visual identification of waveforms. However, bias toward visually striking events restricts the search space for new biomarkers, and low interrater reliability can limit rigorous validation. We present a data-driven approach to biomarker discovery called scalp EEG Pattern Identification and Categorization (s-EPIC), which enables automated, unsupervised identification of EEG waveforms. S-EPIC is validated on Lennox-Gastaut syndrome (LGS), an epilepsy that is difficult to diagnose and assess due to its variable presentation and insidious evolution of symptoms.
We retrospectively collected 10-min scalp EEG clips during non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep from 20 subjects with LGS and 20 approximately age-matched healthy controls. For s-EPIC, EEG events of interest (EOIs) were detected in all subjects using time-frequency analysis. The 11 705 EOIs were characterized based on 11 features and were collectively grouped using both k-means clustering and feature categorization. To provide clinical context, 1350 EOIs were visually reviewed and classified by three epileptologists.
s-EPIC identified four clusters as candidate biomarkers of LGS, each having significantly more LGS EOIs than control EOIs. Two clusters contained EOIs resembling known LGS biomarkers such as interictal epileptiform discharges and generalized paroxysmal fast activity. The other two LGS-associated EEG clusters contained short bursts of power in beta and gamma frequency bands that were primarily unrecognized by epileptologists. This approach also uncovered significant differences in sleep spindles between LGS and control cohorts.
s-EPIC provides a quantitative approach to waveform identification that could be broadly applied to EEG from both healthy subjects and those with suspected pathology. s-EPIC can objectively identify and characterize relevant EEG waveforms without visual review or assumptions about the waveform's morphology and could therefore be a powerful tool for the discovery and refinement of EEG biomarkers.
脑电图(EEG)生物标志物的发现与验证通常依赖于对波形的视觉识别。然而,对视觉上显著事件的偏向限制了新生物标志物的搜索空间,且评分者间的低可靠性会限制严格的验证。我们提出了一种名为头皮脑电图模式识别与分类(s-EPIC)的数据驱动生物标志物发现方法,该方法能够自动、无监督地识别EEG波形。s-EPIC在 Lennox-Gastaut 综合征(LGS)上得到验证,LGS 是一种因症状表现多变且隐匿进展而难以诊断和评估的癫痫。
我们回顾性收集了20名 LGS 患者和20名年龄匹配的健康对照在非快速眼动(NREM)睡眠期间10分钟的头皮 EEG 片段。对于 s-EPIC,使用时频分析在所有受试者中检测感兴趣的 EEG 事件(EOIs)。基于11个特征对11705个 EOIs 进行表征,并使用 k 均值聚类和特征分类将它们集中分组。为提供临床背景,由三名癫痫专家对1350个 EOIs 进行视觉检查和分类。
s-EPIC 识别出四个簇作为 LGS 的候选生物标志物,每个簇中 LGS 的 EOIs 明显多于对照的 EOIs。两个簇包含类似于已知 LGS 生物标志物的 EOIs,如发作间期癫痫样放电和全身性阵发性快活动。另外两个与 LGS 相关的 EEG 簇包含β和γ频段的短功率爆发,癫痫专家基本未识别出这些。该方法还揭示了 LGS 组和对照组在睡眠纺锤波上的显著差异。
s-EPIC 提供了一种波形识别的定量方法,可广泛应用于健康受试者和疑似有病理状况者的 EEG。s-EPIC 无需视觉检查或对波形形态的假设即可客观地识别和表征相关 EEG 波形,因此可能成为发现和完善 EEG 生物标志物的有力工具。