Shefner Ruth T, Johnson Josephine, Shofer Francis S, Anderson Evan D
Department of Sociomedical Sciences, Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, New York, NY, USA.
Department of Sociology and Criminology, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, USA.
J Drug Issues. 2024 Oct;54(4):576-589. doi: 10.1177/00220426231179213. Epub 2023 May 29.
Pre-booking diversion enables police officers to divert individuals to supportive services in lieu of prosecution for minor crimes related to substance use. We surveyed 204 Philadelphia Police Department officers authorized to initiate pre-booking diversions. We used bivariate x tests and multivariate logistic regression to examine differences in respondent perspectives. 78% agreed that pre-booking diversion provides important services to people who use drugs, 69% wanted to expand the geographic score of programming, and 52% wanted to expand eligibility. Yet 59% questioned whether diversion is "what police should be doing", and only 27% believed that it will improve public safety. In logistic regression, the perceived value that the police department places on referrals correlated with agreement that PAD improves safety, provides important services for people who use drugs, and fits within officers' role. Tension between beliefs that the program provides important services but may not improve safety reflects both potential value and inherent challenges of pre-booking diversion models.
预订前分流使警察能够将个人转介至支持性服务机构,以替代对与药物使用相关的轻微犯罪的起诉。我们对204名被授权启动预订前分流的费城警察局警官进行了调查。我们使用双变量x检验和多变量逻辑回归来检验受访者观点的差异。78%的人同意预订前分流为吸毒者提供了重要服务,69%的人希望扩大项目的地理范围,52%的人希望扩大资格范围。然而,59%的人质疑分流是否“是警察应该做的事情”,只有27%的人认为这将改善公共安全。在逻辑回归中,警察部门对转介的重视程度与认为药物辅助治疗能提高安全性、为吸毒者提供重要服务且符合警官职责的观点相关。认为该项目提供重要服务但可能无法提高安全性的信念之间的紧张关系,既反映了预订前分流模式的潜在价值,也反映了其固有挑战。