Chen Minjie, Zhao Xiaojing, Zheng Tao, Zhang Binyuan, Zhao Xuji, Shao Weijun, Li Li, Fan Yiling, Dong Enhong
Department of Outpatient and Emergency Management, Renji Hospital, School of Medicine in Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, People's Republic of China.
Department of thoracic surgery department, Renji Hospital, School of Medicine in Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, People's Republic of China.
BMJ Open. 2024 Dec 12;14(12):e085431. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2024-085431.
The aim of this study is to develop, implement the precise reservation path (PRP) and investigate its prediction function for scheduling shunting patients for specialist appointment registration in Shanghai, China.
The PRP system was built on the hospital's existing information system, integrated with WeChat (WeCom) for user convenience. The outcome analysis employed a mixed-methods approach, integrating quantitative analysis with statistical and machine learning techniques, including multivariate logistic regression, random forest (RF) and artificial neural network (ANN) analysis.
This study was conducted at Renji Hospital, a premier general tertiary care institution in Shanghai, China, where the innovative PRP system was implemented. The programme was designed to efficiently connect patients requiring specialised care with the appropriate medical specialists.
The PRP encompassed both voluntary specialists at Renji Hospital, as well as patients seeking outpatient specialist services.
The pass rates of patient for specialist applications.
Clinical department, specialists' and patients' characteristics influencing specialist review result.
From a data set of 58 271 applicants across 26 departments between 1 December 2020 and 30 November 2022, we noted an overall pass rate of 34.8%. The departments of urology, breast surgery and thoracic surgery, along with five others, accounted for 86.65% of applications. Pass rates varied significantly, and demographic distributions of applicants across departments revealed distinct patient profiles, with preferences evident for age and gender. We developed an RF model based on pass rates from 26 specialised departments. The RF model, with 92.31% accuracy, identified age as the primary predictor of pass rates, underscoring its impact on specialist review outcomes. Focus on patient demographics, we conducted univariate and multivariate logistic regression analyses on the 58 271 patient data set to explore the relationship between demographic factors and review outcomes. Key findings from logistic regression included significant associations with gender, age and specialist title. Results indicated that older patients were more likely to be approved in specialist reviews, while middle-aged patients had lower pass rates. The generalised linear model, enhanced with specialist and clinical department variables, showed superior predictive accuracy (67.86-68.26%) and model fit over the previous logistic model. An ANN model also identified specialist and clinical department as the most influential, achieving comparable accuracy (67.72-68.28%).
The PRP programme demonstrates the potential of digital innovation in enhancing the hierarchical medical system. The study's findings also underscore the value of the PRP programme in healthcare systems for optimising resource allocation, particularly for ageing populations. The programme's design and implementation offer a scalable model for other healthcare institutions seeking to enhance their appointment systems and specialist engagement through digital innovation.
本研究旨在开发并实施精准预约路径(PRP),并在中国上海调查其对分流患者进行专科预约挂号的预测功能。
PRP系统基于医院现有的信息系统构建,并与微信(企业微信)集成,以方便用户使用。结果分析采用混合方法,将定量分析与统计和机器学习技术相结合,包括多变量逻辑回归、随机森林(RF)和人工神经网络(ANN)分析。
本研究在上海一家顶尖的三级综合医疗机构仁济医院进行,该医院实施了创新的PRP系统。该项目旨在有效地将需要专科护理的患者与合适的医学专家联系起来。
PRP涵盖了仁济医院的志愿专家以及寻求门诊专科服务的患者。
患者专科申请的通过率。
影响专科评审结果的临床科室、专家和患者特征。
在2020年12月1日至2022年11月30日期间,对26个科室的58271名申请者的数据集进行分析,我们发现总体通过率为34.8%。泌尿外科、乳腺外科和胸外科以及其他五个科室占申请总数的86.65%。通过率差异显著,各科室申请者的人口统计学分布显示出不同的患者特征,在年龄和性别方面存在明显偏好。我们基于26个专科科室的通过率开发了一个RF模型。该RF模型的准确率为92.31%,确定年龄是通过率的主要预测因素,突出了其对专科评审结果的影响。聚焦于患者人口统计学,我们对58271名患者的数据集进行了单变量和多变量逻辑回归分析,以探讨人口统计学因素与评审结果之间的关系。逻辑回归的主要发现包括与性别、年龄和专家职称有显著关联结果表明,老年患者在专科评审中更有可能获得批准,而中年患者的通过率较低。通过专家和临床科室变量增强的广义线性模型显示出比之前的逻辑模型更高的预测准确率(67.86 - 68.26%)和模型拟合度。一个ANN模型也确定专家和临床科室是最有影响力的因素,其准确率相当(67.72 - 68.28%)。
PRP项目展示了数字创新在加强分级医疗系统方面的潜力。该研究的结果还强调了PRP项目在医疗系统中优化资源分配的价值,特别是对于老年人群体。该项目的设计和实施为其他寻求通过数字创新加强其预约系统和专家参与度的医疗机构提供了一个可扩展的模型。