Mathis Savannah, Schoolfield Suzie, Gross Peggy, Gruen Margaret, Dorman David C
Byram Hills High School, Armonk, NY 10504, USA.
College of Veterinary Medicine, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC 27606, USA.
Animals (Basel). 2024 Nov 28;14(23):3445. doi: 10.3390/ani14233445.
Many domesticated dogs show signs of anxiety, negatively impacting their own and their owner's mental and physical health. A systematic review evaluating whether pressure wraps decrease clinical signs of anxiety in dogs was completed to identify relevant studies. The main outcomes of interest included behavioral and physiological measures. A total of 229 studies were identified, of which four met the inclusion criteria. Commercially available pressure wraps and a telemetry vest were used in the reviewed studies. Three experimental studies included brief exposure to recorded firecracker or thunderstorm sounds or separation from their owner as anxiety-invoking stimuli. A non-experimental study evaluated the use of pressure wraps for dogs with thunderstorm phobia living in their home environment exposed to naturally occurring thunderstorms. The risk of bias in domains related to the blinding of investigators or study participants was generally high. Domains with moderate risk of bias often reflected incomplete reporting of research methods and imprecision due to small sample sizes. Most studies reported minimal benefits on behavior or heart rate in the absence of adverse side effects. Our review suggests there is weak and limited evidence to support the beneficial effect of pressure wraps in reducing physiological or behavioral signs of anxiety. Confidence in the available literature is low due to the moderate-to-high risks of bias and inconsistent findings. Further studies are needed regarding the efficacy of these products.
许多家养犬表现出焦虑迹象,对它们自身以及主人的身心健康产生负面影响。为了确定相关研究,完成了一项系统评价,评估压力包裹物是否能减少犬的焦虑临床症状。主要关注的结果包括行为和生理指标。共识别出229项研究,其中四项符合纳入标准。在综述研究中使用了市售的压力包裹物和遥测背心。三项实验研究将短暂暴露于录制的鞭炮声或雷暴声或与主人分离作为引发焦虑的刺激因素。一项非实验研究评估了压力包裹物对生活在自然雷暴环境中的患有雷暴恐惧症的犬的使用情况。在与研究者或研究参与者的盲法相关的领域,偏倚风险普遍较高。偏倚风险中等的领域通常反映出研究方法报告不完整以及由于样本量小而导致的不精确性。大多数研究报告称,在没有不良副作用的情况下,对行为或心率的益处微乎其微。我们的综述表明,支持压力包裹物在减轻焦虑的生理或行为症状方面具有有益效果的证据薄弱且有限。由于存在中到高的偏倚风险和不一致的研究结果,对现有文献的信心较低。需要进一步研究这些产品的疗效。