Temple Norman J
Centre for Science, Athabasca University, Athabasca, AB T9S 3A3, Canada.
Nutrients. 2024 Nov 26;16(23):4039. doi: 10.3390/nu16234039.
Ultra-processed foods (UPFs) is a food category within the NOVA system. The key feature of UPFs are foods that have been highly processed and contain various additives, especially those that are industrially produced. It is claimed that UPFs are inherently unhealthy. The classification system is highly controversial. This paper critically evaluates the evidence. In stark contrast to conventional systems for food classification, the NOVA system disregards the nutritional values of foods. As a result, many foods generally considered to be healthy are included as UPFs, whereas many unhealthy foods are excluded. Epidemiological studies, mainly prospective cohort studies, have consistently reported an association between the intake of UPFs and risk of obesity, cardiovascular disease (CVD), type 2 diabetes, common mental disorders (especially depression), and all-cause mortality. A similar association has been reported for cancer and hypertension, but the supporting evidence is weaker. The most plausible explanation for this is that the associations are largely due to a limited number of unhealthy foods, such as processed meat and sugar-sweetened beverages. Studies of the relationship between UPFs and obesity present a different picture. There is much evidence that suggests that UPFs play a major causal role in obesity. The high contents of fat, sugar, carbohydrates, and sodium commonly present in UPFs makes these foods hyperpalatable. In addition, UPFs typically have a high energy density. As a result of these two features of UPFs, most people consume an excessive energy intake when presented with UPFs. Because UPFs include a wide range of foods, many of which are healthy, it is likely that while many UPFs are obesogenic, many others are not.
超加工食品(UPFs)是诺瓦(NOVA)系统中的一个食品类别。超加工食品的关键特征是经过高度加工且含有各种添加剂的食品,尤其是那些工业化生产的食品。据称,超加工食品本质上不健康。该分类系统极具争议性。本文对相关证据进行了批判性评估。与传统的食品分类系统形成鲜明对比的是,诺瓦系统忽视了食品的营养价值。因此,许多通常被认为健康的食品被列为超加工食品,而许多不健康食品却被排除在外。流行病学研究,主要是前瞻性队列研究,一致报告了超加工食品的摄入量与肥胖、心血管疾病(CVD)、2型糖尿病、常见精神障碍(尤其是抑郁症)以及全因死亡率之间的关联。对于癌症和高血压也报告了类似的关联,但支持证据较弱。对此最合理的解释是,这些关联很大程度上是由于少数不健康食品,如加工肉类和含糖饮料。关于超加工食品与肥胖之间关系的研究呈现出不同的情况。有大量证据表明,超加工食品在肥胖中起主要因果作用。超加工食品中通常含有的高脂肪、高糖、高碳水化合物和高钠含量使这些食品极具适口性。此外,超加工食品通常能量密度高。由于超加工食品的这两个特征,大多数人在接触超加工食品时会摄入过多能量。由于超加工食品包括种类繁多的食品,其中许多是健康的,很可能虽然许多超加工食品具有致肥胖性,但其他许多并非如此。