Liang Tian, Yilmaz Gizem, Soon Chun-Siong
Centre for Sleep and Cognition, Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, National University of Singapore (NUS), Singapore 117549, Singapore.
Sensors (Basel). 2024 Nov 23;24(23):7475. doi: 10.3390/s24237475.
Cardiovascular diseases are a major cause of mortality worldwide. Long-term monitoring of nighttime heart rate (HR) and heart rate variability (HRV) may be useful in identifying latent cardiovascular risk. The Oura Ring has shown excellent correlation only with ECG-derived HR, but not HRV. We thus assessed if stringent data quality filters can improve the accuracy of time-domain and frequency-domain HRV measures. 92 younger (<45 years) and 22 older (≥45 years) participants from two in-lab sleep studies with concurrent overnight Oura and ECG data acquisition were analyzed. For each 5 min segment during time-in-bed, the validity proportion (percentage of interbeat intervals rated as valid) was calculated. We evaluated the accuracy of Oura-derived HR and HRV measures against ECG at different validity proportion thresholds: 80%, 50%, and 30%; and aggregated over different durations: 5 min, 30 min, and Night-level. Strong correlation and agreements were obtained for both age groups across all HR and HRV metrics and window sizes. More stringent validity proportion thresholds and averaging over longer time windows (i.e., 30 min and night) improved accuracy. Higher discrepancies were found for HRV measures, with more than half of older participants exceeding 10% Median Absolute Percentage Error. Accurate HRV measures can be obtained from Oura's PPG-derived signals with a stringent validity proportion threshold of around 80% for each 5 min segment and aggregating over time windows of at least 30 min.
心血管疾病是全球主要的死亡原因。长期监测夜间心率(HR)和心率变异性(HRV)可能有助于识别潜在的心血管风险。Oura Ring仅与心电图得出的心率显示出良好的相关性,但与HRV没有相关性。因此,我们评估了严格的数据质量过滤器是否可以提高时域和频域HRV测量的准确性。对来自两项实验室睡眠研究的92名年轻(<45岁)和22名年长(≥45岁)参与者进行了分析,这些研究同时进行了夜间Oura和心电图数据采集。对于卧床期间的每个5分钟时间段,计算有效比例(被评定为有效的心跳间隔百分比)。我们在不同的有效比例阈值(80%、50%和30%)下评估了Oura得出的心率和HRV测量相对于心电图的准确性,并在不同持续时间(5分钟、30分钟和夜间水平)上进行汇总。在所有心率和HRV指标以及窗口大小方面,两个年龄组均获得了强相关性和一致性。更严格的有效比例阈值以及在更长时间窗口(即30分钟和夜间)上进行平均提高了准确性。HRV测量发现了更高的差异,超过一半的年长参与者超过了10%的中位数绝对百分比误差。通过对每个5分钟时间段设置约80%的严格有效比例阈值,并在至少30分钟的时间窗口上进行汇总,可以从Oura的光电容积脉搏波描记法(PPG)得出的信号中获得准确的HRV测量值。