Neumann Anne, Subah Marion, van der Westhuizen Helene-Mari
Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK
Charite Medical Faculty Berlin, Berlin, Berlin, Germany.
BMJ Glob Health. 2024 Dec 18;9(12):e016351. doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2024-016351.
Despite their central role in achieving health equity and Universal Health Coverage, only a minority of community health workers (CHWs) is formally recognised as health workforce and receives a salary. Community health policies are formed within the power dynamics of global health practice. We argue that critical investigations of the power dynamics that influence the design of CHW programmes can contribute system-level insights to strengthen their roles.We present a national-level case study of the Liberian Community Health Assistant programme as an exemplar case of successfully introducing a nationwide CHW policy that professionalises CHWs. Using a theory of how power is exercised (Steven Lukes) for our analysis, we argue that Liberia's success in overcoming external funder push-back on the payment of CHWs was enabled by strong political commitment and (re-)claiming government authority in and outside of decision-making processes. Consensus-building across government departments strengthened the government's decision-making power. The availability and strategic use of suitable and contextualised evidence focused on the rights of CHWs allowed for proactive engagement with external funders' concerns. To draw on learnings from the experience of Liberia, we recommend looking beyond the common effectiveness-oriented narratives in academic literature that focus on CHW's functional role. By focussing on how power is exerted through policy negotiations around professionalisation, it could be possible to reframe conventional approaches to the role of CHW in other contexts as well.
尽管社区卫生工作者在实现健康公平和全民健康覆盖方面发挥着核心作用,但只有少数社区卫生工作者被正式认可为卫生人力并获得薪酬。社区卫生政策是在全球卫生实践的权力动态中形成的。我们认为,对影响社区卫生工作者项目设计的权力动态进行批判性调查,可以为加强其作用提供系统层面的见解。我们以利比里亚社区卫生助理项目为例进行国家层面的案例研究,该项目成功引入了一项使社区卫生工作者专业化的全国性社区卫生政策。运用一种关于权力行使的理论(史蒂文·卢克斯)进行分析,我们认为,利比里亚在克服外部资助者对支付社区卫生工作者薪酬的抵制方面取得成功,得益于坚定的政治承诺以及在决策过程内外(重新)主张政府权威。政府各部门之间建立共识增强了政府的决策权。提供并战略性地运用关注社区卫生工作者权利的适当且贴合实际情况的证据,使得能够积极应对外部资助者的关切。为借鉴利比里亚的经验教训,我们建议超越学术文献中常见的以效果为导向的叙述,这些叙述侧重于社区卫生工作者的职能作用。通过关注围绕专业化的政策谈判中权力是如何行使的,也有可能在其他背景下重新构建关于社区卫生工作者角色的传统方法。