Alonso Juan Pedro, Cejas Cintia, Berrueta Mabel, Vazquez Paula, Perrotta Gabriela, Formia Sandra, Pirsch Sofía, Ballivian Jamile, Zavala Denise, López Analía, Belizán María
National Scientific and Technical Research Council (CONICET), Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Instituto de Efectividad Clínica y Sanitaria (IECS), Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Reprod Health. 2024 Dec 18;21(1):187. doi: 10.1186/s12978-024-01927-6.
The effective attainment of sexual, reproductive, and maternal health and rights (SRMHR) requires a holistic life-course approach. This approach should address disparities in healthcare access and rights, guarantee the delivery of high-quality care devoid of discrimination, and underscore rigorous accountability mechanisms throughout the implementation process. Latin American and Caribbean (LAC) countries face significant disparities in SRMHR within and between nations. Vulnerable populations, such as indigenous communities, Afro-descendants, LGBTQI + population, persons with disabilities, older adults, and migrants, often endure discrimination and stigmatization, severely impacting their access to healthcare and health rights. This paper presents the findings from the qualitative component of a broader mixed-methods scoping study aimed at establishing a priority research agenda to address healthcare gaps affecting the SRMHR of vulnerable populations. The qualitative component focused on identifying key challenges hindering progress in SRMHR and access to health services for these populations in the LAC region, drawing on the perspectives of key informants at both regional and national levels.
Qualitative research approach employing semi-structured interviews with key informants. A purposive sample comprised of stakeholders from relevant regional organizations and local stakeholders in selected countries (Argentina, Colombia, Peru, Mexico, Guatemala, Jamaica, and Guyana), encompassing government representatives, civil organizations, and academia. A rapid content thematic analysis was conducted to analyze the data obtained from the interviews.
We interviewed 27 key informants in SRMHR, six at a regional level and 21 at a country level. The region faces barriers around establishing and sustaining agency agendas, such as a lack of political will, political instability, and opposition from civil society groups regarding SRMHR agendas. Policy implementation presents difficulties due to insufficient and unstable funding, weaknesses in sexual and reproductive health programs, unequal policy implementation in federal countries, and the absence of evidence-based policies. The lack of high-quality data and quality indicators poses obstacles, leading to limitations in evidence generation. Access to SRMHR services faces barriers such as the low-quality provision of services, discrepancies between legislation and effective access, insufficient healthcare resources, and resistance from certain healthcare providers.
Addressing these multifaceted challenges will be crucial in advancing the agenda of sexual, reproductive, and maternal health rights and ensuring effective access to health services for the most vulnerable populations in the LAC region.
有效实现性健康、生殖健康及孕产妇健康与权利(SRMHR)需要采取全面的生命历程方法。这种方法应解决医疗保健获取和权利方面的差异,确保提供无歧视的高质量护理,并在整个实施过程中强调严格的问责机制。拉丁美洲和加勒比地区(LAC)国家在国家内部和国家之间的SRMHR方面存在显著差异。弱势群体,如土著社区、非裔后裔、LGBTQI+人群、残疾人、老年人和移民,常常遭受歧视和污名化,严重影响他们获得医疗保健和健康权利的机会。本文介绍了一项更广泛的混合方法范围界定研究的定性部分的结果,该研究旨在确定一个优先研究议程,以解决影响弱势群体SRMHR的医疗保健差距。定性部分侧重于从区域和国家层面的关键信息提供者的角度,确定阻碍LAC地区这些人群在SRMHR方面取得进展以及获得医疗服务的关键挑战。
采用对关键信息提供者进行半结构化访谈的定性研究方法。一个有目的的样本由来自相关区域组织的利益相关者和选定国家(阿根廷、哥伦比亚、秘鲁、墨西哥、危地马拉、牙买加和圭亚那)的当地利益相关者组成,包括政府代表、民间组织和学术界。对从访谈中获得的数据进行了快速内容主题分析。
我们采访了27名SRMHR方面的关键信息提供者,其中6名在区域层面,21名在国家层面。该地区在制定和维持机构议程方面面临障碍,例如缺乏政治意愿、政治不稳定以及民间社会团体对SRMHR议程的反对。由于资金不足且不稳定、性健康和生殖健康项目存在缺陷、联邦制国家政策实施不平等以及缺乏循证政策,政策实施存在困难。缺乏高质量数据和质量指标构成障碍,导致证据生成受到限制。获得SRMHR服务面临障碍,如服务提供质量低下、立法与有效获取之间存在差异、医疗资源不足以及某些医疗服务提供者的抵制。
应对这些多方面的挑战对于推进性健康、生殖健康及孕产妇健康权利议程以及确保LAC地区最弱势群体有效获得医疗服务至关重要。