Pan Ting, Li Chenshuang, Zhou Ying
Center for Smart and Healthy Buildings, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, Hubei 430074, China.
EClinicalMedicine. 2024 Dec 9;79:102994. doi: 10.1016/j.eclinm.2024.102994. eCollection 2025 Jan.
Care dependency, inability to perform basic daily tasks without assistance due to functional impairment, increases substantially with accelerated population ageing and becomes a pressing public health concern worldwide. Socioeconomic disadvantage has been shown to be associated with elevated risks of care dependency, but how risks are modified by changes in socioeconomic position remains unclear. From a life course perspective, we investigated the association between socioeconomic mobility across the lifespan and care dependency in later life.
In this longitudinal multicohort study, we pooled data collected between 2000 and 2019 from six prospective cohort studies across 17 countries from the Program on Global Ageing, Health, and Policy. Socioeconomic status (SES) at three different life stages was assessed based on parental education in childhood, participants' education in early adulthood, and non-housing wealth in middle-late adulthood. Care dependency was measured using activities of daily living (ADLs) and instrumental activities of daily living (IADLs) following WHO recommendations. Ordinal logistic mixed-effect models were applied to investigate associations between socioeconomic inequalities and their mobility across the life course with later-life care dependency. Furthermore, to investigate contributors to inequalities in care dependency, we applied the difference method to estimate the proportion of these inequalities explained by potential risk factors, and quantified the health and economic benefits of targeted interventions using population attributable fractions.
A total of 103,282 individuals were involved in this study, with an average baseline age of 63.29 (SD 10.70) years and a mean follow-up of 8.75 (SD 0.02) years. Low SES at any stage of life was associated with elevated probability, increased severity, and accelerated deterioration of care dependency in later life, with women being particularly vulnerable. For the probability of IADL dependency, socioeconomic differences by parental education persisted and were greatest at ages 75-80 years (18.10%, 95% CI 14.25%-21.95% for women; 10.23%, 5.82%-14.64% for men). Considering the severity of dependency, differences in low ADL dependency reversed in advanced old age, while differences in high ADL dependency widened consistently with age. Differences in high ADL dependency between high and low childhood SES groups increased from 0.66% (0.64%-0.67%) at age 50 to 15.79% (12.19%-19.39%) at age 100. Compared with a stable high SES throughout life, all other SES mobility trajectories were associated with elevated risks of both IADL and ADL dependency. Individuals who experienced a severe SES decline-high in childhood but low in adulthood-showed a more than ten times higher risk (IADL: OR 18.26, 95% CI 12.45-26.79; ADL: 11.95, 8.47-16.88). A lower risk was observed for those who moved from low SES in childhood to high SES in adulthood (IADL: 2.51, 1.00-6.33; ADL: 1.52, 0.62-3.72). Furthermore, out of risk factors ranging from lifestyles, diseases to social connections, lack of social activities was found to be the primary contributor to socioeconomic inequalities in care dependency (explaining up to 66.63%), with corresponding interventions achieving universal health and economic benefits across countries.
Changing socioeconomic status over the lifespan was associated with care dependency risk in later life. Promoting equal educational opportunities from an early age to equitably benefit the most socioeconomically disadvantaged could help mitigate care burdens. Encouraging participation in social activities has the potential to reduce socioeconomic differences in care dependency.
National Natural Science Foundation of China.
由于功能受损而导致在无协助情况下无法完成基本日常任务的护理依赖,随着人口加速老龄化而大幅增加,并成为全球紧迫的公共卫生问题。社会经济劣势已被证明与护理依赖风险升高有关,但社会经济地位变化如何改变这些风险仍不清楚。从生命历程的角度来看,我们调查了一生中社会经济流动性与晚年护理依赖之间的关联。
在这项纵向多队列研究中,我们汇总了2000年至2019年间从全球老龄化、健康与政策项目的17个国家的六项前瞻性队列研究中收集的数据。基于童年时期的父母教育程度、成年早期参与者的教育程度以及成年中后期的非住房财富,评估了三个不同生命阶段的社会经济地位(SES)。按照世界卫生组织的建议,使用日常生活活动(ADL)和工具性日常生活活动(IADL)来衡量护理依赖。应用有序逻辑混合效应模型来研究社会经济不平等及其在生命历程中的流动性与晚年护理依赖之间的关联。此外,为了调查护理依赖不平等的影响因素,我们应用差异法来估计这些不平等中由潜在风险因素解释的比例,并使用人群归因分数来量化针对性干预措施的健康和经济效益。
共有103282人参与了本研究,平均基线年龄为63.29(标准差10.70)岁,平均随访时间为8.75(标准差0.02)年。生命中任何阶段的低社会经济地位都与晚年护理依赖的概率升高、严重程度增加以及恶化加速相关,女性尤其脆弱。对于IADL依赖的概率,按父母教育程度划分的社会经济差异持续存在,并且在75 - 80岁时最大(女性为18.10%,95%置信区间14.25% - 21.95%;男性为10.23%,5.82% - 14.64%)。考虑到依赖的严重程度,低ADL依赖的差异在高龄时逆转,而高ADL依赖的差异则随年龄持续扩大。高、低童年SES组之间高ADL依赖的差异从50岁时的0.66%(0.64% - 0.67%)增加到100岁时的15.79%(12.19% - 19.39%)。与一生都保持高社会经济地位相比,所有其他社会经济地位流动轨迹都与IADL和ADL依赖的风险升高相关。经历严重社会经济地位下降(童年高但成年低)的个体显示出高出十倍以上的风险(IADL:优势比18.26,95%置信区间12.45 - 26.79;ADL:11.95,8.47 - 16.88)。对于那些从童年低社会经济地位转变为成年高社会经济地位的人,观察到较低的风险(IADL:2.51,1.00 - 6.33;ADL:1.52,0.62 - 3.72)。此外,在从生活方式、疾病到社会关系等一系列风险因素中,缺乏社交活动被发现是护理依赖社会经济不平等的主要影响因素(解释比例高达66.63%),相应的干预措施在各国都能实现普遍的健康和经济效益。
一生中社会经济地位的变化与晚年护理依赖风险相关。从早年开始促进平等的教育机会,以使社会经济最弱势群体公平受益,有助于减轻护理负担。鼓励参与社交活动有可能减少护理依赖方面的社会经济差异。
中国国家自然科学基金。