Jencks S F
JAMA. 1985 Apr 5;253(13):1903-7.
Data from the National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey show that the majority of psychotropic drugs and "psychotherapy/therapeutic listening" provided to adults in office-based primary care are given in visits during which no diagnosis of mental disorder is recorded. This finding is not explained either by a general tendency of surveyed physicians to record drug treatment without an appropriate diagnosis or by management of specific nonmental disorders with mental treatments. Patients who receive treatment without diagnosis tend to be older, established patients with established diagnoses who see the physician for a shorter visit and are more likely to have a follow-up appointment. The data do not provide evidence as to whether mental treatment without mental diagnosis results from inadequacies in the current diagnostic system, inadequacies of physician knowledge and skills, or other factors. Further clarification of this issue will require new research models.
来自国家门诊医疗调查的数据显示,在以门诊为基础的初级保健中,提供给成年人的大多数精神药物和“心理治疗/治疗性倾听”是在未记录精神障碍诊断的就诊过程中给予的。这一发现既不能用被调查医生在没有适当诊断的情况下记录药物治疗的普遍倾向来解释,也不能用对特定非精神障碍进行心理治疗来解释。未确诊就接受治疗的患者往往年龄较大,是已有诊断的老患者,看医生的时间较短,且更有可能有随访预约。这些数据并未提供证据表明无精神诊断的心理治疗是源于当前诊断系统的不足、医生知识和技能的不足,还是其他因素。对此问题的进一步澄清将需要新的研究模型。