Frye Willow, Chehab Lara, Feler Joshua, Wong Laura, Tan Amy, Alpers Benjamin, Patel Devika, von Hippel Christiana, Sammann Amanda
Department of Surgery, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, United States.
The Better Lab, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, United States.
Front Public Health. 2024 Dec 18;12:1477473. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2024.1477473. eCollection 2024.
Shared micromobility programs (SMPs) are integral to urban transport in US cities, providing sustainable transit options. Increased use has raised safety concerns, notably about helmet usage among e-scooter and e-bicycle riders. Prior studies have shown that head and upper extremity injuries have risen with SMP adoption, yet data on helmet use remains sparse.
This cross-sectional observational study evaluated helmet use among 5,365 riders (e-bicycles, conventional bicycles, and e-scooters) in San Francisco during February and March 2019. Observations were made at seven key intersections during peak commute hours on clear days.
The majority rode conventional bicycles (77.1%), followed by e-bicycles (19.0%) and e-scooters (3.9%). Most vehicles (82.2%) were personally owned, with the remainder shared via SMPs. Helmet usage was substantially lower among SMP riders, with shared e-scooter users showing the lowest compliance. Specifically, shared e-scooter riders wore helmets 70% less frequently than personal e-scooter riders and 59% less than shared e-bike riders. Dockless e-bike riders used helmets 42% less than those on docked e-bikes.
This study exposes significant gaps in helmet usage among SMP riders, highlighting a pressing need for public health interventions and policy adjustments to improve safety and reduce head injury risks. The findings suggest that helmet use is notably deficient among e-scooter and dockless e-bicycle riders, underscoring the urgent need for targeted safety regulations as cities continue to integrate SMPs into their transportation frameworks.
共享微出行计划(SMPs)是美国城市公共交通的重要组成部分,提供了可持续的出行选择。其使用量的增加引发了安全担忧,尤其是电动滑板车和电动自行车骑行者的头盔使用情况。此前的研究表明,随着SMPs的采用,头部和上肢受伤情况有所增加,但头盔使用数据仍然稀少。
这项横断面观察性研究评估了2019年2月和3月在旧金山的5365名骑行者(电动自行车、传统自行车和电动滑板车)的头盔使用情况。在晴天高峰通勤时段,于七个关键十字路口进行观察。
大多数人骑传统自行车(77.1%),其次是电动自行车(19.0%)和电动滑板车(3.9%)。大多数车辆(82.2%)为个人所有,其余通过SMPs共享。SMP骑行者的头盔使用率显著较低,共享电动滑板车用户的合规率最低。具体而言,共享电动滑板车骑行者佩戴头盔的频率比个人电动滑板车骑行者低70%,比共享电动自行车骑行者低59%。无桩电动自行车骑行者使用头盔的比例比有桩电动自行车骑行者低42%。
本研究揭示了SMP骑行者在头盔使用方面存在显著差距,凸显了公共卫生干预和政策调整以提高安全性和降低头部受伤风险的迫切需求。研究结果表明,电动滑板车和无桩电动自行车骑行者的头盔使用明显不足,强调随着城市继续将SMPs纳入其交通框架,迫切需要针对性的安全法规。