Bushover Brady, Kim Andrew, Mehranbod Christina A, Roberts Leah E, Gobaud Ariana N, Eschliman Evan L, Fish Carolyn, Gao Xiang, Zadey Siddhesh, Goin Dana E, Morrison Christopher N
Department of Epidemiology, Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University, New York, NY, USA.
Department of Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine, School of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, Monash University, Melbourne VIC, Australia.
J Urban Health. 2025 Feb;102(1):82-91. doi: 10.1007/s11524-024-00946-9.
Community violence is a major cause of injury and death in the USA. Empirical studies have identified that some place-based interventions of urban private places, such as remediations of vacant lots and buildings, are associated with reductions in community violence in surrounding areas. The aim of this study was to examine whether routine maintenance and repair of urban public places (e.g., street construction projects) are also associated with reductions in community violence, proxied by violent crime incidents. This staggered adoption difference-in-difference analysis investigated the association between street construction projects and community violence in New York City from 2010 to 2019, divided into 40 calendar quarters. The units of analysis were street-quarters (n = 155,280). Intervention street-quarters were those with completed projects in 2010-2019; control streets were those where projects were scheduled but not completed before 2019. The outcome of community violence was proxied by counts of crime and violence incidents reported to the New York Police Department, within street-quarters. There were 81,904 street-quarters with any community violence incidents (52.7%). We found that street construction projects were associated with a decrease in reckless endangerment (ATT = - 1.3%; 95% CI = - 2.1%, - 0.4%), robbery (ATT = - 3.4%; 95% CI = - 6.1%, - 0.7%), and weapons offenses (ATT = - 1.6%; 95% CI = - 3.0, - 0.08%) occurring on street-quarters. Street construction projects may be yet another type of place-based intervention to reduce community violence.
社区暴力是美国受伤和死亡的主要原因。实证研究表明,一些针对城市私人场所的基于地点的干预措施,如对空地和建筑物的整治,与周边地区社区暴力的减少有关。本研究的目的是检验城市公共场所的日常维护和修缮(如街道建设项目)是否也与以暴力犯罪事件为代表的社区暴力减少有关。这种交错采用的双重差分分析调查了2010年至2019年纽约市街道建设项目与社区暴力之间的关联,共分为40个日历季度。分析单位是街道季度(n = 155,280)。干预街道季度是指在2010 - 2019年有已完成项目的街道;对照街道是指那些项目已安排但在2019年前未完成的街道。社区暴力的结果以向纽约警察局报告的街道季度内犯罪和暴力事件的计数为代表。有81,904个街道季度发生过任何社区暴力事件(52.7%)。我们发现,街道建设项目与街道季度上鲁莽危害行为的减少(平均处理效应 = -1.3%;95%置信区间 = -2.1%,-0.4%)、抢劫(平均处理效应 = -3.4%;95%置信区间 = -6.1%,-0.7%)以及武器犯罪(平均处理效应 = -1.6%;95%置信区间 = -3.0,-0.08%)有关。街道建设项目可能是另一种减少社区暴力的基于地点的干预措施。