Klein S P, Bohannan H M, Bell R M, Disney J A, Foch C B, Graves R C
Am J Public Health. 1985 Apr;75(4):382-91. doi: 10.2105/ajph.75.4.382.
The National Preventive Dentistry Demonstration Program assessed the cost and effectiveness of various types and combinations of school-based preventive dental care procedures. The program involved 20,052 first, second, and fifth graders from five fluoridated and five nonfluoridated communities. These children were examined at baseline and assigned to one of six treatment regimens. Four years later, 9,566 members of this group were examined again. Analyses of their dental examination data showed that dental health lessons, brushing and flossing, fluoride tablets and mouthrinsing, and professionally applied topical fluorides were not effective in reducing a substantial amount of dental decay, even when all of these procedures were used together. Occlusal sealants prevented one to two carious surfaces in four years. Children who were especially susceptible to decay did not benefit appreciably more from any of the preventive measures than did children in general. Annual direct per capita costs were $23 for sealant or fluoride prophy/gel applications and $3.29 for fluoride mouthrinsing. Communal water fluoridation was reaffirmed as the most cost-effective means of reducing tooth decay in children.
国家预防性牙科示范项目评估了各类校内预防性牙科护理程序及其组合的成本与效果。该项目涉及来自五个有氟化物社区和五个无氟化物社区的20,052名一年级、二年级和五年级学生。这些儿童在基线时接受了检查,并被分配到六种治疗方案之一。四年后,该组中的9,566名成员再次接受了检查。对他们的牙齿检查数据进行分析后发现,即使将所有这些程序一起使用,牙齿健康课程、刷牙和使用牙线、服用氟化物片剂和漱口水以及专业应用的局部氟化物在减少大量龋齿方面均无效。窝沟封闭剂在四年内可预防一到两个龋面。特别容易患龋齿的儿童从任何预防措施中获得的益处并不比普通儿童明显更多。每年人均直接成本为:窝沟封闭剂或氟化物预防/凝胶应用23美元,氟化物漱口水3.29美元。社区水氟化被再次确认为减少儿童龋齿最具成本效益的方法。