航空噪音对社区的影响:一项飞行员调查。
Community impacts of aviation noise: a pilot survey.
作者信息
Banks Jamie L, O'Rourke Becky Petrou
机构信息
Quiet Communities Inc., Concord, MA, USA.
formerly Quiet Communities Inc., Concord, MA, USA.
出版信息
J Expo Sci Environ Epidemiol. 2025 Jan;35(1):80-90. doi: 10.1038/s41370-024-00737-z. Epub 2025 Jan 7.
BACKGROUND
Aviation noise policy in the United States is decades old and has not kept up with the science on the adverse effects of chronic noise exposure. New aviation noise policies are needed for the 21 century, respecting the lived experience of affected communities. Existing surveys have reported adverse impacts from aviation noise but more information is needed to understand the factors that contribute to those impacts.
OBJECTIVE
To evaluate the impacts of current aircraft noise exposure on impacted communities and their determinants.
METHODS
A 10-question online community pilot survey was distributed in May 2022 to an email list of groups and individuals in aviation-impacted communities. The survey was open for two weeks. Information on geographic location, frequency of exposure, and type of aircraft exposure were collected. Seven questions focused on the type and magnitude of health impacts, perceptions, and concerns.
RESULTS
A total of 1452 surveys were completed within the 2-week period. Respondents report experiencing loud, repetitive, low-altitude aircraft noise - day and night - causing stress and negative effects on mental and physical health. For many, "annoyance" did not adequately describe their experience. Strong, consistent exposure-response patterns for weekly flight frequency (<100 to >1000 flights) were found for most health impacts, perceptions, and concerns. The likelihood of adverse impacts and heightened perceptions and concerns was greatest in respondents exposed mainly to military aircraft.
SIGNIFICANCE
Current aviation noise policy is based on annoyance, and relies on a metric that exceeds safe levels and does not meaningfully convey community impact. Aviation-impacted communities are experiencing mental and physical health impacts that extend beyond annoyance. The magnitude of impact is influenced by flight frequency and aircraft type. Aviation noise policy should be updated to account for those factors and focus on reducing public health impacts and their human and economic costs.
IMPACT STATEMENT
Aviation noise policy in the United States is decades old and is based solely on the concept of annoyance without sufficient regard to the harms caused to health and well-being of people living in aviation-impacted communities. Efforts to amend the policy must be informed by the scientific evidence on the adverse effects of noise and health and by metrics that properly represent the lived experiences of communities. The results of this pilot survey highlight the importance of incorporating these aspects into policy for preventing and mitigating harms caused by aviation noise, especially as the industry grows.
背景
美国的航空噪声政策已有数十年历史,未能跟上关于长期噪声暴露不利影响的科学进展。21世纪需要新的航空噪声政策,同时要尊重受影响社区的实际经历。现有调查已报告了航空噪声的不利影响,但仍需要更多信息来了解造成这些影响的因素。
目的
评估当前飞机噪声暴露对受影响社区的影响及其决定因素。
方法
2022年5月,向航空受影响社区的团体和个人电子邮件列表分发了一份包含10个问题的在线社区试点调查问卷。该调查开放两周。收集了有关地理位置、暴露频率和飞机暴露类型的信息。七个问题聚焦于健康影响的类型和程度、认知及担忧。
结果
在两周内共完成了1452份调查问卷。受访者报告称,日夜都经历着响亮、重复的低空飞机噪声,这会导致压力以及对身心健康产生负面影响。对许多人来说,“烦恼”并不能充分描述他们的经历。对于大多数健康影响、认知和担忧,发现了每周飞行频率(<100至>1000次航班)的强烈、一致的暴露-反应模式。主要暴露于军用飞机的受访者中,产生不利影响以及认知和担忧加剧的可能性最大。
意义
当前的航空噪声政策基于烦恼程度,所依赖的指标超过了安全水平,且未能有效传达对社区的影响。航空受影响社区正经历着超出烦恼程度的身心健康影响。影响的程度受飞行频率和飞机类型的影响。航空噪声政策应更新以考虑这些因素,并专注于减少对公众健康的影响及其人力和经济成本。
影响声明
美国的航空噪声政策已有数十年历史,仅基于烦恼概念,未充分考虑对生活在航空受影响社区的人们的健康和福祉造成的危害。修订该政策的努力必须以关于噪声与健康不利影响的科学证据以及能恰当体现社区实际经历的指标为依据。这项试点调查的结果凸显了将这些方面纳入政策以预防和减轻航空噪声造成的危害的重要性,尤其是在该行业发展的情况下。